24小时热门版块排行榜    

查看: 33  |  回复: 0

宇宙逻辑

银虫 (正式写手)

[交流] 229、On the Reversed PrimarySecondary Relationship of the Poynting Vector

preprint of cern doi :10.5281/zenodo.22169420
or https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22169420
my academic identifier: orcid id: 0009-0005-2185-5790. you may go to the official academic website to retrieve and view relevant research content.
readers may copy this number to search on the official zenodo website (search by english title or english keywords) to view the full english and chinese pdf texts.


Abstract
Traditional electromagnetic theory uses the Poynting vector to describe electromagnetic energy transmission. It holds that electromagnetic energy is mainly transmitted in the field outside conductors, and conductors only serve to guide electromagnetic fields. This paper adopts the physical criterion: energy loss occurs only when work is done on external substances; if no external work is performed, energy remains and transmits inside the system. Combined with practical engineering phenomena including opencircuit circuits, shielded cables and corona noise of highvoltage transmission lines, analysis is carried out. It shows that electromagnetic fields outside conductors are mostly secondary disturbances derived from charge motion. When such disturbances do work on external substances, those regions are exactly where energy dissipates, rather than the main channel for energy transmission. The Poynting vector treats leaked secondary disturbances as the primary energytransport path, resulting in reversed physical causality. The mechanism of shielded cables reducing loss by suppressing external disturbances doing external work and corona noise of highvoltage lines caused by electromagnetic disturbances dissipating electric energy through work on air molecules can be selfconsistently explained by the workloss criterion. The external magnetic field is merely a secondary sideeffect generated by electron flow inside wires. Even if this sideeffect enables accurate current measurement, it cannot be equated with the main carrier of energy transmission.
Keywords:
Poynting vector; electromagnetic energy transmission; workloss criterion; shielded cable; corona loss; current transformer
1 Introduction
In modern electromagnetic textbooks, the Poynting vector is the standard tool for describing electromagnetic energy flow. Its physical picture states that electric energy is not conducted inside wires. Instead, energy flows in electromagnetic fields surrounding conductors. Metal conductors only constrain and guide external electromagnetic fields so that energy propagates along wires.
This interpretation has long been accepted as established conclusion. Nevertheless, logical contradictions emerge when confronted with abundant practical engineering observations. Why can shielded cables cut energy loss? Why do highvoltage overhead lines produce audible corona noise? Why does energy not dissipate spontaneously for an opencircuit power source? Moreover, current transformers widely used in engineering measure internal wire current by detecting secondary magnetic disturbances outside conductors. Precise measurements are achievable, yet this phenomenon is often misinterpreted, confusing sideeffects with the physical ontology of energy. Existing theories lack one unified simple physical criterion to coherently interpret all abovementioned engineering facts.
This paper abandons the preset assumption that fields act as energy carriers. It applies the workloss criterion to analyze electromagnetic energy flow: energy loss takes place only when the system does work upon external matter. If no external work is performed, energy carried by disturbances stays inside the system and keeps propagating. Based on this rule, the physical picture of electromagnetic energy transmission is reanalyzed. This paper points out that the Poynting vector suffers from reversed primarysecondary causality.

229、On the Reversed PrimarySecondary Relationship of the Poynting Vector
回复此楼
光本源统一理论,物理理论研究者,学术身份ORCID:0009-0005-2185-5790,全部完整研究文稿存档于关联欧洲核子中心的Zenodo预印本平台。完整原文可通过ORCID
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
相关版块跳转 我要订阅楼主 宇宙逻辑 的主题更新
普通表情 龙 兔 虎 猫 高级回复 (可上传附件)
信息提示
请填处理意见