24小时热门版块排行榜    

查看: 850  |  回复: 4
【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题,作者genhaolss将赠送您 5 个金币
当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖,点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

genhaolss

新虫 (初入文坛)

[求助] 大佬们,求助一个审稿人的问题 已有2人参与

我收到两个审稿人的意见,一个回复得很中肯,意见也提得很好,但另一个审稿人意见提得较少,感觉看得不是特别仔细,而且认为我的工作没有太多的创新点,大佬们认为我修改后需要换掉第二个审稿人吗?附第二个审稿人意见:
Comments:
The paper needs improvement on technical grounds.

Additional Questions:
1) Does the paper contribute to the body of knowledge?: Not really. It only proposed marginally improved work.

2) Is the paper technically sound?: To some extent. Please elaborate on SMO within the text. The equations need to be defined first starting from the lowest to the highest level of understanding. In this context, the frequency domain utilizing MCVLMCF needs to be defined at Eq No. 15.
The Algorithms 1 pseudocode can be written more formally rather than just detailed methodology explained.
There is a need for comparative analysis mentioned in Table No. 9 on Datasets COIL100.
The contextual features for overcoming need to be formulated first then the actual comparison is declared.

3) Is the subject matter presented in a comprehensive manner?: Yes to some extent. I am more interested to know the complexity of proposed algorithms with a number of proposed ones. Without this, its is always very difficult to judge the supremacy of the presented results.
Furthermore, there is a need to use the ANOVA test for the comparison that provides statistical inference.

4) Are the references provided applicable and sufficient?: Yes

5) Are there references that are not appropriate for the topic being discussed?: No

5a) If yes, then please indicate which references should be removed.:
回复此楼
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

nono2009

超级版主 (文学泰斗)

No gains, no pains.

优秀区长优秀区长优秀区长优秀区长优秀版主

【答案】应助回帖

感谢参与,应助指数 +1
作者还能要求换审稿人?!好好修改并回复审稿意见吧。
5楼2022-10-02 14:19:22
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
查看全部 5 个回答

风筝不想飞呀

木虫之王 (文坛精英)

【答案】应助回帖

感谢参与,应助指数 +1
既然编辑给了修改机会,尽量按照审稿人的意见一一修改(尤其是第二个审稿人),即使有些问题没有做出实质性的修改,也要尽最大可能说明原因。至于更换审稿人不是稿件作者可以决定的,需要由编辑考量并决定。祝好运
成王败寇
2楼2022-10-02 11:13:16
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

weiyang

新虫 (著名写手)

引用回帖:
2楼: Originally posted by 风筝不想飞呀 at 2022-10-02 11:13:16
既然编辑给了修改机会,尽量按照审稿人的意见一一修改(尤其是第二个审稿人),即使有些问题没有做出实质性的修改,也要尽最大可能说明原因。至于更换审稿人不是稿件作者可以决定的,需要由编辑考量并决定。祝好运

正解

发自小木虫Android客户端
3楼2022-10-02 11:55:23
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
不应助 确定回帖应助 (注意:应助才可能被奖励,但不允许灌水,必须填写15个字符以上)
最具人气热帖推荐 [查看全部] 作者 回/看 最后发表
[考研] 288求调剂 +9 王晓阳- 2026-03-09 12/600 2026-03-10 07:09 by Wahxp
[考研] 一志愿山东大学,总分327,英语二79,有论文,有竞赛,已过四六级 +3 木木目目1 2026-03-09 3/150 2026-03-09 19:52 by yuningshan
[考研] 348求调剂 +3 wyx79618 2026-03-06 7/350 2026-03-09 16:10 by wyx79618
[考研] 0703化学求调剂 +4 很老实人 2026-03-09 4/200 2026-03-09 13:38 by macy2011
[考研] 293一志愿华东理工 0817化学工程与技术 调剂 +5 fjj0912 2026-03-07 5/250 2026-03-09 09:13 by 30660438
[考研] 0817找调剂 +6 kk扛 2026-03-08 6/300 2026-03-09 06:38 by houyaoxu
[考研] 一志愿211 材料与化工 280求调剂 +3 Sanity蒋 2026-03-08 3/150 2026-03-09 06:35 by houyaoxu
[考研] 材料工程330分求调剂,一志愿985 +3 小材化本科 2026-03-07 3/150 2026-03-09 05:35 by houyaoxu
[考研] 一志愿武理314求调剂 +4 ( ̄~ ̄;) 2026-03-08 5/250 2026-03-08 23:12 by L135790
[考研] 材料工程307,求调剂 +4 我要燃烧你的梦 2026-03-08 4/200 2026-03-08 21:07 by 535743368
[考研] 调剂 +3 13853210211 2026-03-08 3/150 2026-03-08 19:34 by ms629
[考研] 求调剂 +3 拾柒12。 2026-03-08 3/150 2026-03-08 17:33 by bingxueer79
[考研] 0817化学工程与技术312分求调剂 +7 T123 tt 2026-03-04 7/350 2026-03-08 11:18 by 我的船我的海
[考研] 材料专硕调剂 +5 慕辰123 2026-03-05 8/400 2026-03-07 15:54 by xuesongli73
[考研] 哈尔滨理工大学2026年研究生调剂,材料科学与化学工程学院研究生调剂 +3 xinliu866 2026-03-06 3/150 2026-03-06 19:42 by 祁东原神
[考研] 085600材料调剂 总分330 +6 池池丶 2026-03-03 6/300 2026-03-06 15:50 by @飒飒飒飒
[考研] 275求调剂 +4 大爆炸难民 2026-03-06 5/250 2026-03-06 09:21 by guoweigw
[考研] 085602 293分求调剂 +3 SivanNano. 2026-03-05 3/150 2026-03-05 19:41 by caszguilin
[考研] 295求调剂 +4 小赛不吃香菜 2026-03-04 4/200 2026-03-04 16:13 by sslc1985
[考研] 085601 材料305分求助 +4 泡泡邮件 2026-03-03 6/300 2026-03-04 13:00 by 无际的草原
信息提示
请填处理意见