24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前主题已经存档。

sun1410

木虫 (小有名气)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 4044.4
帖子: 175
在线: 89.9小时
虫号: 572484
注册: 2008-06-12
专业: 计算数学与科学工程计算

[交流] 大家帮我看看，期刊的邮件是不是说文章接收了？

好久前投了篇文章，修改稿提交后，编辑现在给了回复，说是同意接收，但如果想进一步修改的话，在一个周内回复。(邮件见下面)
      之前的情况是这样的，第一次返回审稿意见时，审稿人希望我能够增加数值试验例子的个数，但返回修改稿时我没有加，我说这些都是经典的例子，类似的文章都是用的这些。
      而这次审稿人没有提其他的问题，只是又把数值试验的事情说了一下，但似乎并不坚持，说决定权在我(But I will not insist on that, and let you decide how much you want to follow this kind advice.)，编辑也已说"accepted for publication"。期刊网上系统中的状态是:

   ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
   |Current Status | Date Final Disposition Set | Final Disposition  |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Accept       |                                     |                         |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------------------

      我不想修改了，打算就这样了，那么我还需要回复编辑吗(邮件中似乎没有说如果不打算修改的话要怎么做)？语言上应该怎么写啊？有模板更佳！

=======修改稿提交后，所投期刊的编辑给的回复=================
Dear Mr. ***,

Your work has now been accepted for publication in ***. however, if you wish to improve it further, inrespond to the reviewer's comments, let me know within a week, and submit the revision in a month, which will be about the time we complete the editorial process and deposit it to the printer.

Thank you for submitting your work to this journal.

With kind regards

***
Editor-in-Chief
***

Reviewer #2: Dear authors,

Thank you for taking into account the referee's comments.

I still think that your algorithm should be tried on a broader set of problems, because your problems are very specific. The optimization community as decided to built test collections to have a clearer view on the efficiency of algorithmic developments.
But I will not insist on that, and let you decide how much you want to follow this kind advice.
==================================================

补充：

      我还没来得及回复，Springer又给我发了封邮件(所投期刊是Springer里的，上面所说的邮件是投的那个期刊发的，非Springer)，说"This message is to let you know that your article Article title: ***, has gone into production. Before we can send you your proofs, we have to ask you to provide some additional information."
      期刊网上系统中的状态也变成了:
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
   |Current Status | Date Final Disposition Set | Final Disposition |
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
   |  Completed    |          **-09-2009       |    Accept       |
   ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

      这表示期刊已经接收了吗？还需要回复期刊的邮件吗？

      第一次经历这些事，还请过来人不吝指教！！！千言万语不足言谢，我还是要先说一声谢谢！！！

Springer发的邮件里，要求 provide some additional information，然后给了个链接，可进去之后说已经 unavailable（邮件中注明是7天的有效期，我是在收到邮件的第二天点的，怎么会过期呢）。发邮件问原因，说是等着重新发链接。怎么会这样呢？？？

[ Last edited by sun1410 on 2009-9-14 at 15:03 ]

回复此楼