[交流] 编辑和审稿人这是啥意思？ 已有9人参与

编辑： Reviewers' comments on your work have now been received.  You will see that they are advising against publication of your work.  Therefore, I must reject it. Please note the journal policy that formally rejected manuscripts are not considered further for publication, irrespective of any subsequent modifications. 审稿人： The subject of this paper is interesting however it seems that it needs more characterization of materials and more results to be acceptable in Electrochemica Acta. There are some few language errors for example for-electron reaction. Nyquist plots must have similar divisions in both axes. More details characterization of materials and reaction products are necessary. The necessity of using toxic chemicals must be evaluated. Authors need to work on XRD test results more to show the exact phase of the electrode (difference between intermetallics and solid solution). Besides they need to describe how is it possible to detect the phase by ICP method. I suggest authors to perform complementary tests and resubmit the revised paper with more complete results. 关键是：审稿人说经完善后可以重投，为啥编辑确这样无情？发邮件问也不回，到底是否可以重投！

回复此楼