[交流] MDPI期刊被拒稿之后，我收到了一封拒稿信 已有12人参与

哎，投了MDPI下面的一个期刊，10.14日投的，今天给了拒稿鼓励重投： 邮件标题：Declined for Publication - Encourage Resubmission after Revisions I am writing to you concerning the manuscript you recently submitted to Minerals. Based on the review reports, the manuscript is not suitable for publication in Minerals in its present format. Significant revisions or new data are required in the manuscript to warrant further consideration for publication of this manuscript in Minerals. Based on reviewer input and editorial evaluation, we encourage resubmission of your manuscript after extensive revisions. During resubmission, you must clearly indicate the manuscript ID (minerals-1441697) of this paper. All changes must be highlighted and a cover letter with responses to reviewers’ comments included. Note that the Editorial Office may send the paper to the same reviewers or invite new reviewers. 一共两个审稿人，一个审稿人的意见是：修改后可以接受 I think this paper can be accepted after revision. 另一个意见比较尖锐，缩短文章长度，（我写的有19页，可能他认为我在水页数？） In my opinion the authors should shorten significantly their manuscript and resubmit it for publication. 我感觉第二个审稿人对我实验理解的不是很到位，当然也可能是我没写清楚。 接下来打算根据审稿意见进行修改，然后重投，希望能有个好结果吧，如果重投不中，我在转投其他期刊！

回复此楼