24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前主题已经存档。

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

一灯

银虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 1935.1
散金: 5
帖子: 144
在线: 68.7小时
虫号: 200261
注册: 2006-02-27
专业: 天文技术和方法

[交流] 【其他】庆祝文章被接收

暑假里一篇文章被Polymer Degradation and Stability（IF=2.3）接受

发金币庆祝一下

感谢所有帮助过我的各位老大

文章09年7月15号投稿，一个月内得到审稿意见^_^
Date: Aug 21, 2009
To: "xxx" xxx@sina.com
From: Tadahisa Iwata atiwata@mail.ecc.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Subject: Your Submission PDST-D-09-00375
Dear Prof. xxx
I have now received comments from a referee on your paper ""Preparation of xxx". They are shown below.
You will see that the reviewer feels that the paper is worth publication, but recommends some changes.
If you would like to prepare a revision along the lines suggested, taking full account of all the points made, I would be happy to accept the manuscript.
Reviewer #1: This paper represents preparation of xxx. This paper is a series of papers reported by same group. Accordingly, it is difficult to find out the scientific novelty in this paper. However, this paper is well written and experimental results are reasonable. Accordingly, this reviewer can recommend this paper to publish to PDST after taking the following points into consideration.
1. Author should describe the scientific novelty in introduction or discussion.
2. There is no experimental data for repeat experiments in the last part in results. Author should add this data.

All best wishes,
Tadahisa Iwata
Editor
Polymer Degradation and Stability

小修返稿，一个星期内得到接收通知^_^
Date: Aug 21, 2009
To: "xxx" xxx@sina.com
From: Tadahisa Iwata atiwata@mail.ecc.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Subject: Your Submission PDST-D-09-00375R1
Ms. Ref. No.: PDST-D-09-00375R1
Title: Preparation of xxx
Polymer Degradation and Stability
Dear Prof. xxx,
I will be pleased to accept your paper for publication. I will send it to the publisher as soon as possible, and you will receive proofs in due course.
Thank you for sending us your paper.
All best wishes,
Tadahisa Iwata
Editor
Polymer Degradation and Stability

几点心得：
1、期刊要合适。这篇文章最初投稿都是档次很高的杂志，偏重于材料类期刊，但都是差一点被接受。后来重新估量文章的科研价值和创新点后，定位到IF2.0左右的聚合物类期刊，结果很快就被接受。
2、文字错误不能有。审稿人很讨厌文章中的小错误，单位、分子式，尤其参考文献一定要按照杂志的要求认真编写，不然原则问题找不到，几个写作上的错误就会断送一篇文章。
3、打一点擦边球。有些杂志为了扩大杂志的影响范围，喜欢收录一些不是很符合本期刊风格的文章。所以可以选择一些不是很搭边的杂志投投，会有意想不到的结果。

[ Last edited by 一灯 on 2009-8-21 at 17:38 ]

回复此楼