24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前主题已经存档。

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

anbb1009

金虫 (正式写手)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 555.6
散金: 100
帖子: 375
在线: 233小时
虫号: 644698
注册: 2008-11-03
专业: 凝聚态物性 II ：电子结构

[交流] JAP 审稿意见下来了，希望木虫上的牛人多多指点。

今天上午打开信箱一看，7月22号投到JAP的paper给出来了审稿意见。本人知道小木虫上牛人很多，希望多多指点。现给出审稿意见：
Review Report:
The investigation of “title***”is interesting. The authors calculated the**** and **** in the Wurtzite InGaN/GaN quantum dots, and present the dependence of****. However, there are many questions about the calculation and the results. A major revision is recommended. Specific points for the authors’ considerations include:
1. The material parameters for the calculation of Fd and Fb in Figs. 1 and 2 should be
provided in the manuscript. In Figs. 1 and 2, Fd decreases with decreasing Lb, and
Fb increases with decreasing Lb. More physical explanation is needed for the
reason in the manuscript. According to the abstract and the text, the barrier width
of 8 nm seems a critical width, but it should be pointed out that it is just for the
material system of In0.1Ga0.9N/GaN.
2. All the parameters that appear in the text should be defined. ei31 and ei33 in Eq. 4 are not defined. Check all the parameters and make sure that they are defined in
the text.
3. The authors performed calculations with varying indium compositions such as
obtaining the results in Fig. 8, but never mention in the text how they considered
the indium composition variation in the calculation. Varying indium compositions
result in varying band gaps and varying material parameter values. The authors
should tell how they performed the calculation with varying indium compositions.
A clearer explanation for the results in Fig. 8 should then be provided.
4. The authors used x and y to represent material compositions, but also used them
for x axis and y axis in Fig. 4. They are confused. Maybe choose different
parameters to represent the compositions.
5. A, B, C, … are used to represent different curves in Figs. 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, and 8. It
would be better to use the real parameters to represent the curves in the figures.
6. The English should be improved in the manuscript.

以上是审稿意见，希望大家能指点迷津.............本人没什么金币，若中散尽金币.....

回复此楼