24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

【有奖交流】积极回复本帖子，参与交流，就有机会分得作者 zhqq2010 的 15 个金币

zhqq2010

银虫 (正式写手)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 1547
散金: 209
红花: 3
帖子: 464
在线: 162.4小时
虫号: 1051727
注册: 2010-07-04
性别: MM
专业: 环境工程

[交流] Nomenclature List 放在哪里合适？

来了专家意见，让修改。麻烦大家给看看。原稿Nomenclature List放在Supporting Information了。现在专家的意思让把Supporting Information中所有内容（图、表、Nomenclature List）弄到manuscript 中。可我的Nomenclature List，有2页纸，超过40多行，放在manuscript 哪部分比较合适啊？是放在 conclusions 后面？虽然英文文章没有版面费，该投稿杂志也没有字数要求，但页数太多也不太好吧？

Reviewer #2: Referee's report：
   The main drawback of the manuscript is the reference to the stand-alone "Supplementary Material" in which the most important results are contained. The article should be homogeneous and the whole "Supporting Information" should be transferred to the manuscript and refined so that all the results and conclusions contained in the manuscript were proven. It seems that the authors (10 people) did not bother to clearly present the obtained results. There must be a homogeneous article without reference to "Supplementary Material".

      To make the article transparent and easy to perception, the list of all Symbols in alphabetic order (appearing both in Equations and Tables/Figs) must be gathered in Nomenclature section.
      The Greek letters should be presented separately in the Nomenclature section also in alphabetic order (as Nomenclature subsection). Please check carefully completeness of the use of appropriate symbols including subscripts.
      Defined by Authors Abbreviations should be consequently presented in the whole manuscript considerably simplifying reading of the manuscript text and improve its clarity.  Abbreviations must be also included at the end of the Nomenclature section (after Greek subsection).

回复此楼