24小时热门版块排行榜    

查看: 15310  |  回复: 31
当前主题已经存档。

yxb19830528

木虫 (著名写手)

高分子材料高工

作者 dmfang  http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=1145750&fpage=1

发此贴是应虫友ahs790808 邀请,他正在给某文章审稿,问是否有审稿的模板。
   审稿写review的话没有什么模板,你可以就文章中一些问题质询作者,或者对文档内容、实验、图表等提出问题或建议,可以分列几条,当然好的 reviewer提的问题是对口的、致命一击的。
   在三年半博士生生涯中,给自己领域内的知名期刊文章审过稿(不是帮老板审稿:)),有四篇。详细的作为审稿人需要注意的和我的审稿经验见我在上海交大读博期间编写的《上海交通大学BBS饮水思源paper(论文)板实用手册(第二版)》:
http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=674559&fpage=1

一.  期刊名:Electrochemical and Solid-State Letters,
   投稿文章:Solenoid Inductors ...
   Author: ...
我的审稿结果:大修
因为这次是网上审稿,因此没有保留我的review意见全文。

二.  期刊名:IEEE Transactions on Components and Packaging Technologies
     投稿文章:Internal Geometry ...
   Author: ...
   我的审稿结果:大修
  
   By using LTCC technology, the authors fabricated the low profile power inductor to improve the light load efficiency of the DC-DC converter. The effects of geometry variation, such as conductor width, core thickness, conductor thickness, number of parallel conductors, on the light load efficiency of the converter were also studied, which will be a good guidance for others to design the similar inductors. What’s more, it is significant that the authors improved the light load efficiency by 30% by decreasing the conductor width of the inductor.
However, the work would be excellent if some mistakes were revised and some explanations were given.
(1)        In part two, the authors assume that there is magnetic isolation between the parallel conductors. I can’t find any necessary explanation. Is it because of the big spacing between the conductors or substrate aspect or other aspects?
(2)        In Fig.13, the 6L5a line decrease obviously after 12A, quite different from other five lines. Is the conductor width 5mm critical size? Why not provide the “Efficiency” result of conductor width 6mm?
(3)        In Fig.14, for the conductor width w=2mm, given the output current, the difference value between two lines is much bigger than that of w=3mm in Fig.16. How to explain this phenomenon.
(4)        There are some spelling mistakes and grammar mistakes in the manuscript. For example, in Eq.(1), the right bracket is missed. In “ACKNOWLEDGMENT”, the quotation mark is unwanted. In reference 8, “Vol.3” should be “Vol.30”. Generally, the sole Arabic number is not used as the initial character in a sentence.

三  期刊名:Microelectronic Engineering
   投稿文章:On-chip embedded ...
   Author: ...
我的审稿结果:大修

This paper presents a novel process for concave-suspended high-performance toroidal inductors and transformers, which are highly demanded in radio-frequency integrated circuits (RF ICs). The fabrication technology is interesting and the RFperformance of the toroidal structures is satisfactory. The introduction, in a clear and understandable fashion, describes the advantages of toroidal structures (inductors and transformers) over straight solenoid structures, such as much little eddy currents and occupying less area.
However, in this paper, the theory to explain why the embedded close-loop structures have high and different performance needs to be improved. In general, the Q-factor of the micromachined inductors can be expressed as [1]
   (1)
where LS is the series inductance of the inductor, RS is the series resistance of the metallization and a frequency dependent term to model skin effect, eddy current effect and other high frequency effects of the inductor, CS is the total parasitic(stray) capacitance. The first factor in Eq.(1) is the intrinsic quality factor of the overall inductance. The middle factor models the substrate loss in the substrate. The final factor models the self-resonance loss due to the overall parasitic capacitances.
In fact, as pointed out in Part Three (Testing Results), the close-loop and air-core can effectively lower the eddy currents and suspending gap over 40 microns can effectively depress the substrate losses. Compared with Fig.8 (a) and Fig.8 (b), except for the turn number, the geometrical parameters per turn of the two toroidal inductors are equal or similar, but the Q-factors are similar below 3GHz and distinguish obviously over 3GHz. Since eddy currents and substrate losses are eliminated, how to explain that the larger number of the square-shaped close-loop solenoid inductor is, the lower the Q-factor is? Is it due to the different average pitch between the adjacent turns, the conductor losses, the parasitic capacitance, or other factors? It is better to give the series resistance and parasitic capacitance versus frequency. The pitch between adjacent turns indeed affects the mutual inductance, i.e., the smaller the pitch is, the larger the mutual inductance and the series inductance is, and vice versa, but we can’t draw a conclusion that “the smaller the pitch is, the better the performance of the inductor or the transformer is”, because the smaller the pitch is, the larger the parasitic capacitance is. Larger parasitic capacitance would decrease the Q-factor [2]. It is strongly recommend expanding the theory to explain the difference of Q-factors versus frequency in Fig.8 (a) and Fig.8 (b).
Because the joints serve as anchors to the frame for robustly suspending the solenoid, so the joints play important roles in the structures. “The fabricated toroidal structures can withstand violent mechanical vibration and thermal strain…”, as mentioned at the beginning of Part Two (Fabrication), but where is the proof? The mechanical stability and the shocking experiment of the concave-suspended straight solenoid inductor have been demonstrated by the authors in an earlier paper [3].
As for the mutual reactive coupling factor k of the transformer, it is necessary to bring forward the significance of k and essential explain, not only simply listed the equation and the pictures of testing results.
The text contains some spelling mistakes, such as “Agilent-HFSS” and “…for a certain inductance values”. “in CMOS compatible silicon wafers”, “on CMOS-compatible silicon wafers”, and “in a 450μm-thick 4-inch silicon substrate”, what is the right preposition? Some sentences require revisions to avoid confusion by the readers. For example, “The formed 4.92nH and 8.48nH toroidal inductors on a low-resistivity silicon substrate are tested with the peak Q of 25.7 and 17.8, while the self-resonant frequencies are 17.3GHz and 7.4GHz, respectively.”
  The following are personal questions. How to choose the geometrical parameters before fabrication? According to HFSS simulation, experiences, or synthetical consideration? In fact, it is important for designers to predict the performance of the structures before they carry out their experiments. Maybe it is one part of the authors’ future work.
Conclusion: Accept with major revision

[3] L. Gu, X.X. Li, Concave-suspended high Q solenoid inductors with an RFIC-compatible bulk
miceomachining technology, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices, 2007, 54: 882-885.


四  期刊名:Journal of Micromechnics and Microengineering
   投稿文章:On The Nonlinear-Flexural...
   Author: ...
我的审稿结果:reject

General assessment
This paper presents the primary resonance of the microcantilever sensors (MCS) under the external exciting without internal resonance. The model for the MCS is based on the nonlinear Euler-Bernoulli beam theory and the first mode of the excited MCS is considered. These will be helpful in some degree for the researchers to study the nonlinear dynamics of the flexible MCS. However, the work in this paper is needed to be improved and the decision for this paper is “reject”.

Comments
1. The most contents in this paper are similar to the published paper [1] written by themselves, especially the Model Formulation, the Reduced-order Modeling and the measured results of the piezoelectrically-excited sensor (ZnO), though the model formulation of the base-excited MCS and the frequency response curves of the piezoelectrically-excited sensor at different quality factors are added by the authors.

2. In the last paragraph of “Introduction”, what does the “material nonlinearities” mean? Understanding this meaning is very important in this paper because it is quadratic nonlinearities, which result the first vibration mode exhibiting a softening-type behavior. As far as I know, the rotation of the flexible beams can induce the quadratic nonlinear term. When the rotation of the flexible beam is in large range, the rotation can change the nonlinear response type. If the “material nonlinearities” is not the rotation term, the flexible beams under rotation, parametric excitation, external excitation should be synthetically concerned with.

3. Because of the nonlinear quadratic term and the cubic term, the internal resonance between two modals (such as 2:1 or 3:1) of the flexible beam is likely to appear. In this paper, the authors did not provide the second modal frequency or the ratio of the first and the second modal frequencies of the flexible beams. If the internal resonance exists, the authors should reconsider the primary resonance with the internal resonance in their future work.

4. In the first paragraphs of “6.1.” and “6.2.”, from Equation (20) and the nonlinear frequency-response curves of figures, “Ω=-0.02ω1” seems to be “σ=-0.02ω1”.

[1] Seyed Nima Mahmoodi, Nader Jalili, and Mohammed F. Daqaq, Modeling, Nonlinear Dynamics, and Identification of a Piezoelectrically Actuated Microcantilever Sensor, IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics, 2008, 13(1): 58-65.

方东明
北京大学微电子学研究院
2009.1.15 19:30
高分子合成及橡胶配方
21楼2009-07-03 09:31:17
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

yxb19830528

木虫 (著名写手)

高分子材料高工

作者 commonman
http://muchong.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=1329206&fpage=1
小弟不才,迄今才撰写了三篇英文文章,但写作过程中也积累了一点经验,不敢敝帚自珍,今天也斗胆向各位虫友贡献一下。我这几篇文章,不论内容如何,但每次审稿人对于语言的评价都是还不错的,well written,总结起来不外有三个小窍门:

一是平时多积累。我在日常读文献的时候,如果发现很好的句子句式,都会记录在一个文档里面,如下面的一段话,就是我在一篇文章的摘要中发现的:

This paper describes the concept of sensor networks which has been made viable by the convergence of microelectro-mechanical systems technology, wireless communications and digital electronics. First, the sensing tasks and the potential sensor networks applications are explored, and a review of factors influencing the design of sensor networks is provided. Then, the communication architecture for sensor networks is outlined, and the algorithms and protocols developed for each layer in the literature are explored. Open research issues for the realization of sensor networks are also discussed.

文章用词忌重复,中文如此,英文亦然。特别是动词的使用,如在一段话中出现了几个相同的动词,感觉文章就跌价不少,而如果用了几个意思相近而又贴切的词,自然就会增色几分。如上文中的describe,explore,provide,outline和discuss,就使得文章有了文采,值得学习和收藏。坚持收集例句,素材多了,自然自己的造句的时候就有底子了。此外,还要注意,在收集例句的过程,随着例句的增多,也需要对例句进行整理和分类,方便学习和检索。

二是注意行文中Transition words的使用。Transition words就是在行文过程中,连接意义相关句子的词,如Therefore,thus,in particular等等。使用这些词,会使得文章连贯性好,逻辑性强,读起来一气呵成,自然会给审稿人好印象。下面是一个关于Transition words的一个总结,供各位虫友参考:

Transitions Study Sheet

Transitions for time:
before, afterward, after, next, then, as soon as, later, until, when, finally, last, meanwhile, during, at times, sometimes, oftentimes

Example: WWII broke out in Europe in 1939.  During this time the United States remained neutral.  It wasn’t until 1941, after Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, that the United States entered the war.  After its entry, it was only a matter of time before the Allies defeated Germany and the Axis powers.

Transitions for place:
in the background, in the distance, beyond, behind, above, below, in front of, elsewhere, in the middle, to the left, to the right

Example:  My favorite painting is Botticelli’s Birth of Venus.  In the middle of the painting stands Venus, the Roman goddess of love, standing on a seashell.  She floats majestically above the beautiful water below her.  To her left a figure representing wind blows fierce clouds of wind in her direction.  To her right a figure behind her attempts to cover her with a blanket and protect her.  It is a truly breath-taking piece of art.

Transitions for examples:
for example, for instance, as an example, like, specifically, consider as an illustration, that is, such as, similar, similarly

Example:  Oftentimes people who study from history fail to learn from the mistakes of the past.  For example, during WWII Hitler decided to invade Russia just before wintertime.  This decision was the same decision Napoleon made over a hundred years earlier, and Hitler’s army met a similar fate.  Had he learned from his history, Hitler might have avoided making this costly mistake and the outcome for the war might have been different.  For instance, if Hitler had decided to invade England by sea rather than Russia by land, he might well have won the war.

Transitions for emphasis:
chiefly, equally, indeed, even more important, in particular, most important, without a doubt, indubitably, unquestionably, definitely

Example:  Without a doubt, Chinese food is one of my favorite cuisines.  Although I find Japanese and Thai food equally delicious at times, Chinese food is definitely my favorite Asian cuisine.  In particular I enjoy the spicy Szechuan style of cooking commonly found in Chinese food.

Transitions for restatement:
in short, that is, in effect, in other words


Example:  When I asked my girlfriend to marry me she said, in effect, that she wouldn’t be ready for marriage until after she completed her PhD program.  At first I was crushed, that is, I felt like she said no because she didn’t love me anymore.  However, after she explained her reasons to me I felt better and agreed with her.  In other words, I came away feeling better than I had anticipated.

Transitions for comparison:
similarly, likewise, also, the same as, different than, opposite, unlike, instead

Example:  When my older brother was deciding where to go to college he spoke to my father about where he should go.  Not surprisingly he went to the same school my father did, MIT.  When it was time for me to choose a college I did the exact opposite.  I didn’t ask my father where I should go, and as a result, I didn’t also go to MIT like he and my brother did.  Instead I went to UCLA.

Transitions for concession:
although, of course, admittedly, true, doubtless, granted that, no doubt, indubitably, without a doubt, definitely, certainly

Example:  Some people might be surprised to learn that the two most successful NBA teams of all-time are the Boston Celtics and the Los Angeles Lakers.  Although neither of these teams is very good right now, they are the two teams with the most champions in NBA history.  The Celtics definitely had the best streak of these two teams; winning eight championships in a row at one point.  Admittedly there is always the chance that some future team could break this record, but this seems unlikely.  Of course no one can predict the future with any certainty.

Transitions for consequence:
thus, so, then, it follows, as a result, therefore, hence, consequently, accordingly, because

Example:  I’m sorry, but I can’t let you turn in your homework late because it wouldn’t be fair to the other students.  As a result your grade has dropped lower and you are now failing the class.  Consequently you need to get 100% on the final so you can pass the class and then graduate from CAS.  Therefore, I suggest you study very hard so I don’t have to fail you.  Good luck!

Transitions for conclusion:
to sum up, in summary, finally, therefore, thus, in conclusion, to conclude

Example:  Finally, Beijing has a lot of nice places to shop that appeal to tourists.  To sum up then, Beijing is a wonderful place to visit because it has beautiful parks and historical monuments, friendly people and lots of nice places to shop.  Thus any travelers who are planning to come to China should definitely visit Beijing during their stay.

Transitions for addition:
furthermore, in addition, besides, next, first, second, moreover
Example:  UCLA is a wonderful university to attend as an undergraduate.  First, it is respected academically and is well-known for its high standards of education.  Furthermore, UCLA has a strong network of alumni who often recruit students to come work for them.  Moreover students who do such work as undergraduates often receive jobs with these same companies once they graduate.  In addition to these two benefits, UCLA also has exciting sports teams that are fun to watch.  Besides, with so many good reasons to go to UCLA, why would you want to go anywhere else?

我的第三条经验就是句酷网站,www.jukuu.com,一个专门找例句的网站,也许有些虫友也知道。我们写文章的时候,很自然会想到一些中文的表达方法,但是常常苦于找不到贴切的英文表达,查电子词典,往往凑出来的句子也是面目全非。句酷网站提供了一个很好的查找例句的渠道(不是广告奥,呵呵),你可以通过中英文关键字,找到很多例句。比如,我想说“值得指出的是”,在句酷里面查了一下,找到了如下几个句子:
It is worth emphasizing that...
it is worth pointing out that ...
A point worth emphasizing is that...
感觉都还不错,都可以选用。更为关键的是,这些例句一般都会有出处,这样就可以根据例句内容和出处来选择比较地道的表述了。我的一个经验是,对于来自cnki.net的例句就得小心点,这些都是国内兄弟写的文章中的句子,常常不是很合适。

今天起得早,又睡不着,写这点东西,希望能对大家有一点点启发。上个月自己的第一篇trans的minor revision刚刚投出去,这些天一直在焦急的等待中,写点东西与大家分享,也顺便给自己祈祈福。第一次在小木虫写帖子,希望大家能喜欢,欢迎大家一起讨论,批评指正,谢谢!
高分子合成及橡胶配方
22楼2009-07-03 09:32:04
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

mindhunter

木虫 (著名写手)

好贴,帮顶
23楼2009-07-03 10:30:58
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

研究生9806

铜虫 (小有名气)

zan!


小木虫(金币+0.5):给个红包,谢谢回帖交流
1.science, nature materials, advanced materials, applied physics letters, scripta materialia这几个网址有用
24楼2009-07-08 19:05:28
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

li21grams

金虫 (正式写手)

很集中,很受用!
25楼2009-07-08 19:08:37
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

aimit

木虫 (职业作家)

工作做的不错。
研究方向机器学习及其应用,欢迎交流讨论。
26楼2009-07-08 19:16:33
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

haojigong

木虫 (正式写手)

很好,很强大
27楼2009-07-08 19:22:09
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

leejane_ren

铁杆木虫 (正式写手)

legend


小木虫(金币+0.5):给个红包,谢谢回帖交流
楼主太猛了,原来是高人,好长时间没见到高人了,向您致敬!
大家好
28楼2009-08-20 22:53:29
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

kyang2009

禁虫 (正式写手)

本帖内容被屏蔽

29楼2009-08-21 10:33:20
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

ice509

铜虫 (小有名气)

学习了,顶一下
30楼2009-08-28 16:49:49
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
相关版块跳转 我要订阅楼主 yxb19830528 的主题更新
普通表情 高级回复 (可上传附件)
信息提示
请填处理意见