24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前主题已经存档。

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

flyhit

铁虫 (正式写手)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 65.5
帖子: 951
在线: 1.6小时
虫号: 435396
注册: 2007-08-25
性别: GG
专业: 机械结构强度学

[交流] APL申诉换来major revision，请高手指点！

投稿APL，第一次审稿人给拒了，编辑也没啥话说。审稿人的意见是让我补很多的相关的细节数据，但一篇APL篇幅非常有限，我提出申诉，并做了部分修改。重新投稿，这次审稿人和编辑都建议修改，但"No"实在太多，心里很没底，嘀咕着“编辑这回不会在玩我吧”。这些要补的东西自己考虑了应该能搞定，就是得花点时间。
特请高手指点，不甚感激！

修改稿：
主编的意见：
The reviewer's comments are included below and/or attached. In view of his/her recommendations, we cannot accept your paper for publication in its present form. If you revise the paper to meet the reviewer's objections, we will be happy to give it further consideration.

审稿意见：
Manuscript #L09-*****R:
Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #2 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Reconsider for APL after mandatory revision (major)
Paper Interesting: No
Original Paper: Yes
Sufficient Physics: No
Well Organized: No
Clear and Error Free: No
Conclusions Supported: No
Appropriate Title: No
Good Abstract: Yes
Satisfactory English: No
Adequate References: No
Clear Figures: Yes
OVERALL RATING: Fair
Reviewer #2 (Comments to the Author):
This manuscript has some important information that will be useful to the development of ***, but it needs some additional attention to *** in order to interpret the data comprehensively and unambiguously.
... ........
I suggest that the authors revise their manuscript to include this critical data, and to incorporate it more comprehensively in their interpretation

********************************************
初稿：
Manuscript #L09-*****:
Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Reject
Paper Interesting: No
Original Paper: Yes
Sufficient Physics: Yes
Well Organized: No
Clear and Error Free: No
Conclusions Supported: No
Appropriate Title: No
Good Abstract: No
Satisfactory English: No
Adequate References: Yes
Clear Figures: Yes
OVERALL RATING: Poor

回复此楼