24小时热门版块排行榜

北京石油化工学院2026年研究生招生接收调剂公告

返回列表

【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题，作者空空如也0将赠送您 50 个金币

空空如也0

新虫 (正式写手)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 76.3
散金: 102
红花: 1
沙发: 1
帖子: 435
在线: 98.4小时
虫号: 9512889
注册: 2018-07-17
专业: 计算机软件

[求助] 给了一个月的修订时间，我10天就改好了。我要不要等到一个月后再投？已有6人参与

审稿意见：
Reviewer #1: I understand that AL-based approach needs both "initial training set" and "the newly added samples" in order to select most representative samples. However, there are two questions. First, what do you mean representative samples? Does it mean a set of samples which covers both valid and invalid links? Second, it seems that in the Algorithm 1, active learning relies on the termination condition to ensure the representativeness of the samples. If I am correct, the termination condition used in the paper (i.e., the number of labeled samples reaches a preset value) does not make any sense. A better termination condition could be the labeled samples shall contains at least 1 valid link and 1 invalid link.

Reviewer #2: Tracking the relation between artifacts in software project is important. Generally, it is human intensive task to construct the traceability links.
Traditional information retrieve techniques has been employed to automatic analyze and recover traceability links. Even machine learning approaches as adopted to train an effective predictive model for traceability link recovery. It requires humans to label traceability links.

This paper presents a TLR approach based on active learning. Evaluation experiments were conducted on seven commonly used traceability datasets. It was compared with an IR-based approach and a current machine learning approach. The experiment shows that AL-based approach outperforms the other two approaches in terms of F-score.

Concerns

1、 Page1, "(hereafter called AL-based approach)" is repeated in the abstract and introduction.
2、 Page 1, section 1, left column, last line, "traceability" means "traceability relationships" or "traceability links"?
3、 Page 2, left column, "TSL-based approach is that how to select traceability links for labeling to generate traceability information."=》that
4、 Page 3, Section 3, Step1: (1)" randomly selecting a small number of samples for labeling to initialize Dt", =>"randomly labeling a small number of samples to initialize Dt "
5、 Page 3, Section 3, Step1: (3) "selecting an unlabeled sample from the unlabeled sample set based on sample selection strategy and requesting experts to label the sample"=> The authors need to define the D and Dl here. Regarding to the context, the Dt and Dl seem equivalent, why use different symbol?
6、 Page 3, Section 3, Step 4, This paper chose Random Forest as the classification algorithm. However, the authors only claimed that "The reason for choosing Random Forest is because it has been shown to be accurate and robust". It would be better to explain why random forest is more suitable for the task.
7、 Page 4, Algorithm1 needs to be reconstructed. It would be much better to define input and output, as well as all the variables used in the algorithm.
8、 Section 4. It would be much better to move Experimental metric at the beginning of section 4. Authors use the F-score before its definition.
9、 The format of refences should be standardized, especially, the names and abbreviations of journals and conferences.

[考研] 309求调剂 +3	快乐的小白鸽 2026-04-04	3/150	2026-04-04 14:31 by 土木硕士招生
[基金申请] 同年申报，是不是就不会派给你函评本子了？ +4	redcom 2026-03-29	4/200	2026-04-04 10:08 by kudofaye
[考研] 26调剂 086003 +6	失活的细胞 2026-04-04	6/300	2026-04-04 09:50 by zhangdingwa
[考研] 求调剂，一志愿郑州大学材料与化工专硕，英二数二342分，求老师收留 +17	v12abo 2026-04-02	19/950	2026-04-04 09:16 by 来看流星雨10
[考研] 387求调剂 +4	爱吃片豆土 2026-04-03	5/250	2026-04-04 08:10 by 岸上的一条鱼
[考研] 材料调剂 +11	一样YWY 2026-04-02	11/550	2026-04-03 23:46 by hemengdong
[考研] 材料科学与工程339求调剂 +12	hyz0119 2026-03-31	13/650	2026-04-03 18:33 by ls刘帅
[考研] 化学调剂 +9	艾志恒 2026-04-03	10/500	2026-04-03 15:51 by 晴空210210
[考研] 324求调剂 +12	想上学求调 2026-04-02	12/600	2026-04-03 11:15 by linyelide
[考研] 专硕 351 086100 也是考的材科基本科也是材料 +8	202451007219 2026-04-02	8/400	2026-04-03 09:50 by 蓝云思雨
[考研] 366求调剂一志愿东北大学 +8	运气来得若有似� 2026-04-02	8/400	2026-04-02 21:39 by dongzh2009
[考研] 318求调剂，计算材料方向 +10	吸喵有害笙命 2026-04-01	11/550	2026-04-02 16:29 by oooqiao
[考研] 材料专硕322分 +11	哈哈哈吼吼吼哈 2026-04-01	11/550	2026-04-02 10:52 by lnilvy
[考研] 材料求调剂 +10	呢呢妮妮 2026-04-01	13/650	2026-04-02 09:17 by olim
[考研] 290求调剂 +5	dfffsar 2026-03-29	5/250	2026-04-01 19:45 by 6781022
[考研] 353求调剂 +4	拉钩不许变 2026-04-01	4/200	2026-04-01 18:10 by 记事本2026
[考研] 08工科，295，接受跨专业调剂 +6	lmnlzy 2026-03-31	6/300	2026-04-01 11:02 by 逆水乘风
[考研] 318求调剂 +8	七忆77 2026-04-01	8/400	2026-04-01 10:37 by Jaylen.
[考研] 本科211生物医学工程085409求调剂339分 +7	里子木yy 2026-03-29	7/350	2026-03-31 14:35 by fmesaito
[考研] 本科211安全工程，初试290分，求调剂 +3	2719846834 2026-03-28	3/150	2026-03-31 13:52 by 热情沙漠

24小时热门版块排行榜

[求助] 给了一个月的修订时间，我10天就改好了。我要不要等到一个月后再投？ 已有6人参与

» 猜你喜欢

【答案】应助回帖

【答案】应助回帖

【答案】应助回帖

【答案】应助回帖

[求助] 给了一个月的修订时间，我10天就改好了。我要不要等到一个月后再投？已有6人参与