24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

douglasxiong

新虫 (初入文坛)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 10.4
帖子: 31
在线: 11.2小时
虫号: 1373439
注册: 2011-08-19
专业: 计算机应用技术

[求助] 审稿人意思是不是叫我用他指定的7篇论文做对比实验？已有1人参与

投稿到Signal processing，大修。文章目前有41页，已经与6篇其他文献做了对比实验。而审稿人3的意思好像是要求我与另外7篇文章做对比。
（1）是不是审稿人3的意思要求我再增加7篇？还是叫我换掉原来的7篇文献？
      我原来做对比实验的6篇文献分别来自Nonlinear Dynamics，Neurocomputing， Multimedia Tools & Applications， Optics Communications。而审稿人3叫我做对比实验的文章分别是下面7篇（怎么看这7篇文章是一伙的）：
      [1] Khan J S, Ahmad J, Khan M A. TD-ERCS map-based confusion and diffusion of autocorrelated data[J]. Nonlinear Dynamics, 2016, 87(1):1-15.
   [2] Kanso A, Ghebleh M. An efficient ( t, n )–threshold secret image sharing scheme[J]. Multimedia Tools & Applications, 2016, 76(15):1-20.
   [3] Ahmad J, Khan M A, Hwang S O, et al. A compression sensing and noise-tolerant image encryption scheme based on chaotic maps and orthogonal matrices[J]. Neural Computing & Applications, 2016:1-15.
   [4] Kanso A, Ghebleh M. An algorithm for encryption of secret images into meaningful images[J]. Optics & Lasers in Engineering, 2017, 90:196-208.
   [5] Rehman A U, Khan J S, Ahmad J, et al. A New Image Encryption Scheme Based on Dynamic S-Boxes and Chaotic Maps[J]. 3d Research, 2016, 7(1):1-8.
   [6] Ahmad J, Khan M A, Ahmed F, et al. A novel image encryption scheme based on orthogonal matrix, skew tent map, and XOR operation[J]. Neural Computing & Applications, 2017(3):1-11.
   [7] Khan J S, Ahmad J. Chaos based efficient selective image encryption[J]. Multidimensional Systems & Signal Processing, 2018(4):1-19.
（2）各位，我第一次投Signal Processing，请问我该怎么处理审稿人3的意见？下面是审稿人3的意见：

Reviewer #3: The authors proposed "文章的题目". It is interesting. However, I have some questions as follows:

1) There are many typing and grammatical errors in several places listed as follows:
6条需要修改的英文语句.

2)  I wish there are comparisons with others. The other representative methods such as: based on TD-ERCS based confusion and diffusion, Dynamic S-Box, DNA Compression Sensing, etc. The papers are related with these methods please refer to Nonlinear Dynamic (2017) 87: 93. doi.org/10.1007/s11071-016-3028-2; Multimedia tools and application 10.1007/s11042-016-3917-x; Neural Computing and Applications, doi.org/10.1007/s00521-016-2405-6; Optics and Laser in Engineering 10.1016/j.optlaseng.2016.10.009; 3D Research, doi.org/10.1007/s13319-016-0084-9.
对应的是上面列出的文[1~5]，这是要我做对比实验吗？

3) The scheme is a bit complex, therefore, add flowchart for your proposed scheme.
需要加流程图

4)  Irregular deviation and Maximum deviation should be done and compared with the following articles. Kindly refer to Neural Computing and Applications, doi.org/10.1007/s00521-017-2970-3.
对应上面列出的文[6]，这个对比实验一定要做吗？

望有经验的同行指点迷津 ...............................................

5) There are many related studies, such as Multidimensional Systems and Signal Processing, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11045-018-0589-x; on the encryption algorithm based on the chaotic system in recent years, in order to show your innovations, contrast tests should be done and compared with these articles.
对应的是上面列出的文[7]，这个对比实验一定要做吗？

At last, I suggest the authors must carefully handle the above comments. If having good revision, then I am willing to review again.

回复此楼