|
|
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
cxksama(金币+5,VIP+0):谢谢分享 4-24 22:43
【期刊名称】：Physical Review Letters----- Physical Review B----------Journal of the physical society of Japan
【投稿日期】：2006.12.14
【最终接受日期】：2009.4.20
可以给大家看看在PRL和PRB里面的记录：
12Nov08 Editorial decision and/or referee comments sent to author
01Oct08 28Oct08 Review request to referee; report received
15Oct08 21Oct08 Reminder to referee; response received
30Sep08 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
24Sep08 29Sep08 Correspondence sent to author; response received
22Sep08 23Sep08 Correspondence sent to author; response received
19Sep08 Acknowledgment sent to author
17Sep08 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
17Sep08 Transferred from PRL to PRB
03Jun08 17Sep08 Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd
16May08 21May08 Sent on appeal; report received
04Mar08 08May08 Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd
11Feb08 26Feb08 Review request to referee; report received
11Feb08 26Feb08 Review request to referee; report received
11Feb08 25Feb08 Review request to referee; report received
31Jan08 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
30Jan08 31Jan08 Corr. to author (paper too long to review); response received
17Jan08 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
22Mar07 17Jan08 Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd
26Mar07 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
26Mar07 Communication (miscellaneous) received from author
22Feb07 15Mar07 Review request to referee; report received
09Mar07 09Mar07 Reminder to referee; response received
22Feb07 02Mar07 Review request to referee; report received
06Feb07 08Feb07 Review request to referee; message received (not a report)
06Feb07 07Feb07 Review request to referee; message received (not a report)
22Jan07 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
16Jan07 21Jan07 Correspondence sent to author; response received
26Dec06 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
18Dec06 25Dec06 Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd
20Dec06 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
20Dec06 Communication (miscellaneous) received from author
14Dec06 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
【投稿感受和体会】：从2006年底开始投prl，也算是我第一篇外文第一作者的文章，那个时候英语写作也太不成熟了，结果第一次送审，编辑直接给拒了，说是文章研究的问题不重要。后来改过了introduction的部分，强调了研究的意义，就送审了。然后就是两个审稿人的意见，说结果不那么令人信服。我就先把一部分次要的数据拿出来，单独写了一篇小文章，刚好凑够了毕业答辩的要求，先毕业了。文章就先搁在那了半年，同时补做了更多的实验。等后来出国找了博后的位置，国内的老板让我改改，再投。我加入了新的数据，完全改写了文章，再投出去。这时就已经是2008年初了。
等审稿意见回来以后，一个表示可以接受，一个仍然拒绝，然后送第三个审稿人审，但是结果非常负面，把实验数据批的一钱不值。就把我的文章给拒了。5月份的时候，这边的一个美国访问教授帮我写了申诉信，最后试了一下，还是被拒绝了。我就又转投prb的rapid communication,希望能被接受，但是审稿人要求增加数据，我无论如何也做不到。这下连prb也没戏了。 再下来,不甘心投journal of physics : condensed matter, 于是我盯上了Journal of the physical society of japan, 感觉在上面的文章质量比较高，就再一次改投到那边。 这次的审稿意见一个月就来了，结果这个审稿人发现了文章中的一个问题，这是前面的所有其他人审稿人都没有注意到，包括我自己。根据这个审稿人的意见，重新估算了参数，修正了错误。前几天最终接收了。 这篇文章从第一次投到最后，一共两年半，改了不下100遍。但是每次都还能不断的改进。我自己的英语写作水平也是靠着不断地改这篇文章而进步。虽说没有发到prl上去，但是还是很幸运，不然最后那个错误就留在文章里面了。说不定哪天就被人指出来，很难看吧。 而且跟审稿人还是能学习很多东西，他们看问题真是非常深刻。 |
|
回复此楼