|
|
★
小木虫(金币+0.5):给个红包，谢谢回帖交流
【期刊名称】：applied catalysis B
【投稿日期】：2009.6 29
【网上预审】：2009. 6.30网上预审通过
【专家评审】：2009.7.1
【审回通知】：2009.9.29 大修,
【提交修改搞通知】：2008.10.7
【审回通知】：2009.10.20小修,
【提交修改搞通知】：2009.10.20
【接收】 ：2009.10.27
该杂志工作量要求大, 我的文章工作量不大,但是比较有新意, 因此审稿人就让我我过了,可能我运气比较好吧
Reviewer #3: The authors have used DFT calculations to calculate Gibbs free energies for the formation of monoactin, diacetin and triacetin from the reaction of glycerol with either acetic acid or acetic anhydride in order to support their recently published experimental data. This is an interesting approach that should be considered for publication.
Nevertheless, there is one minor comment on the script left that should be reconsidered:
P5 paragraph 4, line 3 et sqq.: "Esterification reaction is initiated by the transfer of a proton from the catalyst.". Here, the authors restate the reaction mechanism for the esterification on a catalyst as was probably proposed in ref. [33]. Within the subsection 3.2, that first explains the data of Table 1 which was obtained without a catalyst and the subsequent discussion of Mulliken population analysis that also does not consider a catalyst, it should be clarified how the information of ref. [33] supports here the general discussion. The way it is written now seems a little misleading.
[ Last edited by castep on 2009-11-7 at 15:28 ] |
|
回复此楼