±±¾©Ê¯ÓÍ»¯¹¤Ñ§Ôº2026ÄêÑо¿ÉúÕÐÉú½ÓÊÕµ÷¼Á¹«¸æ
²é¿´: 6306  |  »Ø¸´: 26
¡¾ÐüÉͽð±Ò¡¿»Ø´ð±¾ÌûÎÊÌ⣬×÷Õßrchml½«ÔùËÍÄú 10 ¸ö½ð±Ò

rchml

гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

[ÇóÖú] ÂÛÎı»¾Ü£¬±à¼­¸øµÄÀíÓÉ¡£´ó¼Ò¾õµÃÎÒ°´ÕÕÒâ¼û×öºÃ¶Ô±ÈʵÑéÊÒ£¬ÍêÉÆÏ£¬¿ÉÒÔÖØÍ¶Ã´£¿ ÒÑÓÐ2È˲ÎÓë

In view of the criticisms of the reviewer(s) found at the bottom of this letter, your manuscript has not been recommended for publication. Unfortunately, we will not accept resubmissions of this article.

Thank you for considering -----------for the publication of your research.

Sincerely,

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Reviewer: 1

Recommendation: Reject

Comments:
A model-based real-time robust controller design problem for a small-size helicopter is studied. This reviewer has the following comments:
-The new features are not clear, especially in comparisons with the recent relevant ones. Robust control of helicopter is a quite traditional problem. Comparisons should be made in both the theoretical and experimental aspects.
-The theoretical contributions seem weak as there is no theorem in this paper.
-Experiment videos or links for the experiment video should be provided.
-The presentation can be further improved. There are too many typos.



Additional Questions:
Does the paper contribute to the body of knowledge?: y

Is the paper technically sound?: n

Is the subject matter presented in a comprehensive manner?: n

Are the references provided applicable and sufficient?: y


Reviewer: 2

Recommendation: Reject

Comments:
The airticle addresses the tracking problem of small-sized helicopter, the controller includes two parts, the part of inner-loop based on H¡Þ technique and the part of outer-loop which adopts PPC method.The idea is interesting and it presents a unique approach to design outer-loop controller.But there are some limitations and key problems.
1.There is no specific comparison of the method with previously known research result, so it is hard to judge whether the algorithm is an improvement on previous work. Some simulation or experiment results of comparison should be added.
2.The configuration design of controller is sound, but stability of the whole system should be considered or explained. The study did not show enough about these problems. Some some trajectory tracking results are needed as a practical and unambiguous evidence.
3.the subject is presented synthetically and the analysis about helicopter modeling is described attentively. The description of the design process of the controller is methodical. But, here are some irregular and oversized formulas which can be reformat.
4.In my opinion, the references about the research on PPC in recent years should be added. The length of introduction about H¡Þ technique can be shorter.

Additional Questions:
Does the paper contribute to the body of knowledge?: Yes

Is the paper technically sound?: Yes

Is the subject matter presented in a comprehensive manner?: It's not bad

Are the references provided applicable and sufficient?: Need to improve
»Ø¸´´ËÂ¥

» ²ÂÄãϲ»¶

ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
»ØÌûÖ§³Ö ( ÏÔʾ֧³Ö¶È×î¸ßµÄǰ 50 Ãû )

xiaogao0859

гæ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

¡ï
sesame_oil: ½ð±Ò+1, ¹ÄÀø½»Á÷ 2017-12-19 14:45:08
±à¼­ËµÁË£¬²»½ÓÊÜÖØÍ¶

·¢×ÔСľ³æIOS¿Í»§¶Ë
3Â¥2017-12-19 01:33:14
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

rchml

гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
2Â¥: Originally posted by 523156717 at 2017-12-19 01:24:42
²»ÊǾܾøÖØÍ¶ÁËô

ÎÒµÄÒâ˼ÊÇ´ó¸Åºó°´ÕÕһƪеÄÎÄÕÂ

·¢×ÔСľ³æIOS¿Í»§¶Ë
4Â¥2017-12-19 01:51:01
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

rchml

гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
3Â¥: Originally posted by xiaogao0859 at 2017-12-19 01:33:14
±à¼­ËµÁË£¬²»½ÓÊÜÖØÍ¶

´ó¸Äºó°´ÕÕеÄÎÄÕÂͶ¸åÄØ

·¢×ÔСľ³æIOS¿Í»§¶Ë
5Â¥2017-12-19 01:51:36
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

lijlsdau

гæ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¡ï
sesame_oil: ½ð±Ò+1, ¹ÄÀø½»Á÷ 2017-12-19 14:45:19
È˼Ҳ»ÊÇ˵ÁËÂð£¬ÄãÖØÐÂͶҲ²»Òª

·¢×ÔСľ³æAndroid¿Í»§¶Ë
ÄÍÐÄ¡¢Ï¸ÐÄ¡¢ÓÃÐÄ
16Â¥2017-12-19 09:52:53
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

rchml

гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
6Â¥: Originally posted by 523156717 at 2017-12-19 01:54:54
ÄÇ»¹²»ÈçÖØÐ´

ÆÀÉóÒâ¼ûÎÒ¾õµÃ²»ÊǺÜÖÂÃü ²»¹ýȱÉÙ¶Ô±ÈʵÑéȷʵÊÇÎÒÓеã͵ÀÁµÄ

·¢×ÔСľ³æIOS¿Í»§¶Ë
7Â¥2017-12-19 01:57:40
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

rchml

гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

¶ÔÁË ÎÒͶµÄIEEE ACCESS
8Â¥2017-12-19 03:35:05
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

anla_123456

гæ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
6Â¥: Originally posted by 523156717 at 2017-12-19 01:54:54
ÄÇ»¹²»ÈçÖØÐ´

ÖØÐ´ÖØÍ¶¡£Ç¿µ÷Ò»ÏÂв¹³äµÄÄÚÈÝ¡£

·¢×ÔСľ³æAndroid¿Í»§¶Ë
9Â¥2017-12-19 03:45:49
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

rchml

гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
16Â¥: Originally posted by lijlsdau at 2017-12-19 09:52:53
È˼Ҳ»ÊÇ˵ÁËÂð£¬ÄãÖØÐÂͶҲ²»Òª

°¦£¬Ð¡µÜ×ÜÊÇ»³ÓлÃÏë¡£
17Â¥2017-12-19 10:29:26
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

xiaogao0859

гæ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

¡ï
sesame_oil: ½ð±Ò+1, ¹ÄÀø½»Á÷ 2017-12-19 14:46:25
±à¼­¶¼ËµÁË£¬ÖØÍ¶Ò²²»Òª£¬Ó¢ÎĻظ´ÖÐÓÐ

·¢×ÔСľ³æIOS¿Í»§¶Ë
18Â¥2017-12-19 10:29:36
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

anla_123456

гæ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
10Â¥: Originally posted by rchml at 2017-12-19 05:45:11
¾ÍÊÇ¿´µ½±à¼­Ëµ²»ÔÊÐíresubmit ²»ÖªµÀÕâÖÖÇé¿öÌíÁËÄÚÈÝËãresubmit »¹ÊÇиå¼þÖØÍ¶
...

ÖØÐÂͶ¡£µ±×÷ÐÂÎÄÕÂͶ¡£

ÖØÍ¶µÄʱºî°ÑмÓÄÚÈÝÇ¿µ÷д£¬Öظ´Ð´¡£²»ÒªËµÊÇresubmit.

¸öÈ˾­Ñ飬¹©²Î¿¼¡£

·¢×ÔСľ³æAndroid¿Í»§¶Ë
19Â¥2017-12-19 10:51:27
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
ÆÕͨ»ØÌû

523156717

½ð³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¡ï
sesame_oil: ½ð±Ò+1, ¹ÄÀø½»Á÷ 2017-12-19 14:45:25
²»ÊǾܾøÖØÍ¶ÁËô

·¢×ÔСľ³æAndroid¿Í»§¶Ë
2Â¥2017-12-19 01:24:42
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

523156717

½ð³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¡ï
sesame_oil: ½ð±Ò+1, ¹ÄÀø½»Á÷ 2017-12-19 14:45:35
ÄÇ»¹²»ÈçÖØÐ´

·¢×ÔСľ³æAndroid¿Í»§¶Ë
6Â¥2017-12-19 01:54:54
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

rchml

гæ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

ÒýÓûØÌû:
9Â¥: Originally posted by anla_123456 at 2017-12-19 03:45:49
ÖØÐ´ÖØÍ¶¡£Ç¿µ÷Ò»ÏÂв¹³äµÄÄÚÈÝ¡£
...

¾ÍÊÇ¿´µ½±à¼­Ëµ²»ÔÊÐíresubmit ²»ÖªµÀÕâÖÖÇé¿öÌíÁËÄÚÈÝËãresubmit »¹ÊÇиå¼þÖØÍ¶

·¢×ÔСľ³æIOS¿Í»§¶Ë
10Â¥2017-12-19 05:45:11
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
Ïà¹Ø°æ¿éÌø×ª ÎÒÒª¶©ÔÄÂ¥Ö÷ rchml µÄÖ÷Ìâ¸üÐÂ
²»Ó¦Öú È·¶¨»ØÌûÓ¦Öú (×¢Ò⣺ӦÖú²Å¿ÉÄܱ»½±Àø£¬µ«²»ÔÊÐí¹àË®£¬±ØÐëÌîд15¸ö×Ö·ûÒÔÉÏ)
×î¾ßÈËÆøÈÈÌûÍÆ¼ö [²é¿´È«²¿] ×÷Õß »Ø/¿´ ×îºó·¢±í
[¿¼ÑÐ] Ò»Ö¾Ô¸ÉúÎïÓëÒ½Ò©£¬296·Ö£¬Çóµ÷¼Á +8 66¹ 2026-04-03 9/450 2026-04-03 14:22 by »¯Ñ§»¯¹¤Ë¶Ê¿ÕÐÉ
[¿¼ÑÐ] 335Çóµ÷¼Á +5 ÉòÇåÁ§ 2026-04-03 5/250 2026-04-03 12:03 by wxiongid
[¿¼ÑÐ] 338Çóµ÷¼Á£¬Ò»Ö¾Ô¸ÄÜÔ´¶¯Á¦£¬ÍâÓïÊÇÈÕÓï203 +5 zzz£¬£¬r 2026-04-02 5/250 2026-04-03 09:45 by À¶ÔÆË¼Óê
[¿¼ÑÐ] ²ÄÁÏר˶322·Ö +10 ¹þ¹þ¹þºðºðºð¹þ 2026-04-02 10/500 2026-04-02 21:46 by dongzh2009
[¿¼ÑÐ] Ò»Ö¾Ô¸´ó¹¤Ñ§Ë¶£¬Çóµ÷¼Á +4 yub0811 2026-04-02 4/200 2026-04-02 21:36 by °ÙÁéͯ888
[¿¼ÑÐ] һ־Ըɽ¶«´óѧ£¬085600£¬344 +7 κ×Óper 2026-04-02 8/400 2026-04-02 21:12 by °ÙÁéͯ888
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085602»¯¹¤Çóµ÷¼Á£¨331·Ö£© +9 111@127 2026-03-30 9/450 2026-04-02 20:00 by dick_runner
[¿¼²©] ²ÄÁϹ¤³Ìרҵ˶ʿÉ격 +3 ÷ëÕýÓî 2026-03-30 3/150 2026-04-02 15:04 by greychen00
[¿¼ÑÐ] 0856³õÊÔ324·ÖÇóµ÷¼Á +6 ÏëÉÏѧÇóµ÷ 2026-04-01 6/300 2026-04-02 11:42 by ÐÇ¿ÕÐÇÔÂ
[¿¼ÑÐ] 295²ÄÁϹ¤³Ìר˶Çóµ÷¼Á +19 1428151015 2026-03-27 19/950 2026-04-01 22:34 by peike
[¿¼ÑÐ] 279Çóµ÷¼Á +7 Īxiao 2026-04-01 7/350 2026-04-01 22:05 by ¿Í¶ûÃÀµÂ
[¿¼ÑÐ] 0703Ò»Ö¾Ô¸ÄÏʦ´ó334Çóµ÷¼Á +4 seven7yu 2026-03-30 4/200 2026-04-01 16:10 by oooqiao
[¿¼ÑÐ] »·¾³¹¤³Ì 085701£¬267Çóµ÷¼Á +15 minht 2026-03-29 16/800 2026-04-01 10:13 by li_sujuan99
[¿¼ÑÐ] ¿¼ÑÐÉúÎïÓëÒ½Ò©µ÷¼Á +7 Ìúº©º©123425 2026-03-31 7/350 2026-04-01 08:45 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] Çóµ÷¼Á ÉúÎïѧ 377·Ö +6 zzll03 2026-03-31 6/300 2026-03-31 17:33 by ÌÆãå¶ù
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085404 22408 315·Ö +5 zhuangyan123 2026-03-31 6/300 2026-03-31 13:48 by limeifeng
[¿¼ÑÐ] 293Çóµ÷¼Á +3 ĩδmm 2026-03-30 5/250 2026-03-30 17:23 by Íõ±£½Ü33
[¿¼ÑÐ] 348Çóµ÷¼Á +6 СÀÁ³æ²»ÀÁÁË 2026-03-28 6/300 2026-03-30 10:29 by Evan_Liu
[¿¼ÑÐ] 356Çóµ÷¼Á +4 gysy?s?a 2026-03-28 4/200 2026-03-29 10:32 by ÌÆãå¶ù
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085405 ¿¼µÄ11408Çó¸÷λÀÏʦ´ø×ß +3 Qiuѧing 2026-03-28 3/150 2026-03-28 09:19 by ÀֺǺǵÄ×·ÃÎÈË
ÐÅÏ¢Ìáʾ
ÇëÌî´¦ÀíÒâ¼û