24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

影子19800208

新虫 (正式写手)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 2794.9
散金: 31
红花: 1
帖子: 336
在线: 85.9小时
虫号: 4182832
注册: 2015-10-29
专业: 金属基复合材料

[求助] 电化学试验数据需要标偏差吗

本人不是专门研究电化学的，课题研究的是应力腐蚀，最近写了一篇文章，里面有一部分是电化学辅助分析镁合金的耐腐蚀性，审稿人提了一个意见，不太明白什么意思，关于试验重复性的，电化学高手帮忙指导下吧。万分感谢！
审稿人意见如下：
For experimental work, do the authors substantiate the extent to which the experiments were replicated, or variability of results assessed, to justify their conclusions on trends or comparative behavior?: The authors do not substantiate the extent to which the experiments were replicated to justify conclusions.The same goes for the corrosion current density values - error bars are a must given the similarity in the magnitude. (Minor point here - why the three decimal precision on the quoted values?). Error bars are reported with the SSRT data, so it is rather perplexing why the same care was not given to the grain size and corrosion kinetic data.

电化学数据也要标偏差吗？印象中看的文献，电化学部分没有标偏差的啊？还有Minor point here - why the three decimal precision on the quoted values这句话是说我的电化学数据为什么保留小数点三位吗？电化学数据应该保留几位有效数字？

回复此楼