24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题，作者aygxy_lhc将赠送您 30 个金币

aygxy_lhc

铁虫 (正式写手)

应助: 5 (幼儿园)
金币: 210.1
散金: 1116
红花: 4
帖子: 482
在线: 826.3小时
虫号: 2483088
注册: 2013-05-26
专业: 化工热力学和基础数据

[求助] 做模拟计算的论文，审稿意见中有一条是关于error bars的，不知该怎么回复，请赐教！

如题，做计算的，水平一般，我是引用别人的数据，然后自己做个模型进行计算，将计算值与实验值进行对比，观察模型的精度（有附图）；最近收到一篇论文的修改意见，其中有一条：Error bars should be added and explained in the figure captions.

我的问题是：
(1)在原文献中，一个点只有一组固定的数据，没有多次测量结果或者是不确定的区间，因此无法获得error bars 的数据；自己重复实验又不太现实;

(2)查了一些跟我论文相近的文献，在experimental versus calculated data 图中（目的主要是观察模型的计算值与实验值是否吻合，以衡量其精度），大部分也未加error bars;

因此我准备将以上两条作为依据，诚恳回答审稿人，error bars就不加了 , 不知可行否？请给出您的建议，谢谢了！

PS：其实审稿意见较多，大概十余条（上面的仅是其中的一条，其余的我努下力应该还可以）：
- Poorly constructed sentences and full of grammatical errors. Authors should revise the manuscript thoroughly specially for grammar, spelling and languages.
- Introduction section needs a major revision. This section must be rewritten in a standard way.
- Keywords: Arrange by alphabet order.
- The main advantages and disadvantages of present study must be added.
- Provide the literature assessment and cite the studies, and mention very clearly the difference from previous studies and the novelty of this study.
- Error bars should be added and explained in the figure captions.
- Some information's should be given in Figure and Table legends about experimental conditions.
- Conclusion section must be improved.
- Abstract should contain some quantitative information also.
- The conclusion should be rewritten.
- More detailed of experimental section is needed.
References must be checked and updated, Please add following references in introduction, Statistical analysis and Results and discussion section:
审稿人自己发表的论文，这就不列了！