| 查看: 2015 | 回复: 1 | ||
ming815zhao木虫 (正式写手)
|
[求助]
ACS审稿意见 —— 如何答复？ 已有1人参与
|
|
投了一票ACS的文章，其中一个审稿人（意见是小修）给了比较外围的评论。 请各位高手指点一下，评审意见的准确意思是什么？如何答复比较妥当？ 万分感谢！ Most importantly to be of the practical significance that they authors are talking about, the materials not only need to be supported, but supported on large particles, typically mm in size. One of the pressing issues in nanoparticle catalyst syntheses is how can the interior pores of 10A or so be wetted by nanoparticles of similar size at a mm distance within the particle. Using fine powder supports gets around this issue but it is not a fair comparison. In most cases, one would make an eggshell on a larger particle support and this could definitely limit how much material can be placed on the support without having large particles easily agglomerated. This is a key issue in there type of materials and it is not touched on in this paper. So in summary some of the data presented here is interesting, but the syntheses is not really scaleable to very large quantity catalyst formulation and the supports used are also not ones that can be used for real applications. So there is a bridge that must be crossed and I would have liked to have seen that described or worked on if this is going to be rated as a top 20% paper. So the beginning of an excellent study is here but there is much still lacking. The journal will decide if this is enough to meet their publication criteria- it just seems to me that this paper is directed toward practical applications and in that vein, it falls short of addressing some key issues. |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
关于合成MIL-125的求助
已经有0人回复
-
双非本硕光催化方向想读博，请各位老师看看我！
已经有2人回复
-
物理化学论文润色/翻译怎么收费?
已经有114人回复
-
瑞典林雪平大学范立洲课题组现招聘博士后、岗位制博士生
已经有0人回复
-
中国科大仿生界面材料科学全国重点实验室戴懿涛研究员/江雷院士团队招聘科研助理
已经有0人回复
-
中国科大仿生界面材料科学全国重点实验室戴懿涛研究员/江雷院士团队招聘科研助理
已经有0人回复
-
寻求物理化学学报最新的投稿模板！
已经有4人回复
-
东南大学杰青/海优团队招聘催化方向博士后
已经有866人回复
-
投稿咨询
已经有7人回复
-
自科面上 散金币 祈福
已经有61人回复
-
铁钼催化剂成型
已经有1人回复
zspcceshi5 
木虫 (正式写手)
★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
温心若水: 金币-20, 屏蔽内容, 违规存档, 请认真应助，遵守版规 2017-07-17 17:01:33
温心若水: 金币-20, 屏蔽内容, 违规存档, 请认真应助，遵守版规 2017-07-17 17:01:33
|
本帖内容被屏蔽 |
2楼2017-07-17 10:28:56
28