24小时热门版块排行榜

>论坛更新日志 (3662)
>博后之家 (190)
>论文投稿 (162)
>导师招生 (156)
>文献求助 (101)
>有机交流 (80)
>虫友互识 (70)
>硕博家园 (67)
>招聘信息布告栏 (38)
>考博 (19)
>学术会议 (15)
>找工作 (15)
>休闲灌水 (13)
>考研 (9)
>基金申请 (8)
>教师之家 (6)

返回列表

【有奖交流】积极回复本帖子，参与交流，就有机会分得作者江其山的 75 个金币

江其山

新虫 (小有名气)

应助: 2 (幼儿园)
金币: 33.5
帖子: 58
在线: 24小时
虫号: 4086084

[交流] 散尽所有金币在线求助分析审稿意见

今天收到了一审审稿意见，所以下面的审稿意见是大修还是修改后重投啊？
投稿系统上面显示如下：
Revise and Resubmit as a Regular Magazine Paper (15-Nov-2016)
Due on: 27-Dec-2016
编辑回复如下：
Reviews of your paper, "********" have been returned and are copied below. These reviews, and the recommendation of the associate editor, indicate that although your paper is not ready for publication in its present form, a properly revised version is potentially publishable.

Therefore, I suggest that you revise your paper along the lines described by the reviewers and resubmit the paper.
The suggested length of a Magazine Regular Paper is 8 pages (authors' biographies excluded).

Please include a description on how you took into account the reviewers' comments in preparing your revision. We would then hope to determine a publication decision soon thereafter. Please note that if your revision is not submitted within the next 6 weeks, your paper will be treated as a new paper.

Thank you for submitting your manuscript to the ***********.

Sincerely,

Prof. *******
Editor-in-Chief
***********
四个审稿人，意见分别如下：
Reviewer: 1
Recommendation: Accept With Minor Changes
Additional Questions:
Summary of Evaluation: Good

Reviewer: 2
Recommendation: Accept
Additional Questions:
Summary of Evaluation: Good

Reviewer: 3
Recommendation: Reject
Additional Questions:
Summary of Evaluation: Fair

Reviewer: 4
Recommendation: Prepare A Major Revision For A New Review
Additional Questions:
Summary of Evaluation: Good

Editor's comments:
Editor
Comments to the Author:
Please read the review comments carefully and make a major revision of your paper.

审稿人3感觉比较负责，提了要害性的问题，然后reject，并且说如果被拒了让我重投这个期刊。这样的审稿意见真是冰火两重天啊。两级分化太严重了。
但是不知道是大修还是改后重投？看编辑的语气好像是大修make a major revision，但是投稿系统却是显示：Revise and Resubmit as a Regular Magazine Paper
Revise and Resubmit在审稿意见里面算什么等级的？比大修还严重点？
请大家指点一二啊。谢谢。

回复此楼