| 查看: 7015 | 回复: 31 | |||
| 本帖产生 1 个 PC-EPI ，点击这里进行查看 | |||
| 当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖 | |||
小达达达银虫 (正式写手)
|
[交流]
前后历经仨月，终于第二篇JAP被接收！
|
||
|
首先为虫友们贴出文章审稿的过程，这篇文章是我这半年的一个结晶之作，选择投JAP也是因为它在我们领域受众很广，影响力不错。而且我前一篇文章从投稿JAP到最终接收只花了一个月的时间： Revised Manuscript Received from Author 01-Aug-2016 02:16:47 Waiting for Revised Manuscript from Author 15-Jul-2016 16:02:54 Decision Sent to Author 15-Jul-2016 16:02:54 Decision Letter Being Prepared 15-Jul-2016 15:42:12 Associate Editor Decision Completed 15-Jul-2016 15:42:12 Associate Editor Decision Started 13-Jul-2016 18:36:04 All Reviews Received 13-Jul-2016 18:36:04 Review Received 13-Jul-2016 18:36:04 All Reviewers Secured 04-Jul-2016 17:21:49 Review Started 04-Jul-2016 17:21:48 Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 04-Jul-2016 17:21:48 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 04-Jul-2016 17:19:54 Potential Reviewers Selected 04-Jul-2016 17:19:47 Additional Reviewers Needed 04-Jul-2016 17:18:48 Reviewer Assignment Started 03-Jul-2016 06:20:57 Additional Reviewers Needed 03-Jul-2016 06:20:57 Potential Reviewer Declined to Review 03-Jul-2016 01:29:52 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 30-Jun-2016 07:22:35 Potential Reviewers Selected 30-Jun-2016 07:22:28 Additional Reviewers Needed 30-Jun-2016 07:22:07 Review Received 27-Jun-2016 03:34:37 Reviewer Assignment Started 24-Jun-2016 18:21:45 Additional Reviewers Needed 24-Jun-2016 18:21:45 Potential Reviewer Declined to Review 24-Jun-2016 14:43:52 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 22-Jun-2016 06:42:36 Potential Reviewers Selected 22-Jun-2016 06:42:27 Additional Reviewers Needed 22-Jun-2016 06:35:00 Reviewer Assignment Started 16-Jun-2016 12:20:58 Review Started 15-Jun-2016 05:56:35 First Reviewer Secured 15-Jun-2016 05:56:35 Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 15-Jun-2016 05:56:35 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 14-Jun-2016 09:19:34 Potential Reviewers Selected 14-Jun-2016 09:19:28 Additional Reviewers Needed 14-Jun-2016 09:18:44 Reviewer Assignment Started 13-Jun-2016 12:21:43 Additional Reviewers Needed 13-Jun-2016 12:21:43 Potential Reviewer Declined to Review 13-Jun-2016 11:39:17 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 10-Jun-2016 06:10:35 Potential Reviewers Selected 10-Jun-2016 06:10:30 Additional Reviewers Needed 10-Jun-2016 06:08:02 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 10-Jun-2016 06:07:53 Potential Reviewers Selected 10-Jun-2016 06:07:49 Reviewer Assignment Started 08-Jun-2016 14:38:53 Securing Associate Editor 07-Jun-2016 12:37:57 Securing Editor 07-Jun-2016 12:37:57 Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed 07-Jun-2016 12:37:57 Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 07-Jun-2016 06:53:30 Securing Editor 07-Jun-2016 06:53:30 Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 07-Jun-2016 06:53:29 Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files 07-Jun-2016 06:45:47 File Conversion Completed 07-Jun-2016 06:45:47 Waiting for File Conversion 07-Jun-2016 06:44:39 File Conversion Completed 07-Jun-2016 06:31:10 Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 07-Jun-2016 06:27:54 File Conversion Completed 07-Jun-2016 03:31:56 一审被仨个审稿人据审有没有！！这对于经常刷系统看审稿进程的人儿的心脏是多么强烈的考验！！已经记不清，有多少次我深夜中惊醒，是梦到编辑由于找不到审稿人直接退稿......不得不佩服AIP的编辑，在1个月的时间内居然找了6个审稿人来约稿。 在经历38天的时间后，一审的结果终于下来了，结果很是令人忐忑： 两个审稿人，一个人在肯定我工作的同时，提出了一些格式上的小问题，原理上也提出了一些问题；另一个把我的工作指责了一番，各种层次的痛批，各种“No”,建议据稿。 但编辑最后给的是大修。 Reviewer Comments: Reviewer #1 Evaluations: Significant Advance: Yes New Research: Yes Innovative Technology: Yes Scientific Advances: Yes Real World Applications: Yes English Correct: No Good Title: Yes Descriptive Abstract: Yes Good Figures: No Adequate References: Yes Reviewer #2 Evaluations: Significant Advance: No New Research: No Innovative Technology: No Scientific Advances: No Real World Applications: No English Correct: No Good Title: Yes Descriptive Abstract: Yes Good Figures: No Adequate References: No 之后我针对这两个人的意见进行了细细的修改，三周之后，我上传了一个21页纸的response letter（近6000字），其中对于两位审稿人的意见回复使用了均等的篇幅。对第二个审稿人，我着重针对他的观点进行了反驳，认为他并没有理解我文中的真正意思。这个response letter我还是很满意的，毕竟把自己的意思全表述出来了，也对于自己很有自信！！ 之后又进入了漫长的等待期。终于，在历经1个月之后在8.31时我终于看到了审稿状态变成了“Associate Editor Decision Completed”。但这才是真正折磨人的开始！！系统停留在Decision Letter Being Prepared足足有三天！！当时我就各种猜测编辑在干嘛，发个据稿或者接收有那么难吗？后来，当我看到最终的decision letter时，我知道了原因。 Stage Start Date Manuscript Sent to Production 02-Sep-2016 20:00:52 Manuscript Ready for Production 02-Sep-2016 16:59:22 Decision Sent to Author 02-Sep-2016 16:59:22 Decision Letter Being Prepared 31-Aug-2016 03:58:29 Associate Editor Decision Completed 31-Aug-2016 03:58:29 Associate Editor Decision Started 30-Aug-2016 19:13:06 All Reviews Received 30-Aug-2016 19:13:06 Review Received 30-Aug-2016 19:13:06 All Reviewers Secured 30-Aug-2016 19:07:03 Review Started 30-Aug-2016 19:07:03 Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 30-Aug-2016 19:07:03 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 29-Aug-2016 16:54:53 Reviewer Assignment Started 27-Aug-2016 06:21:02 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 25-Aug-2016 00:34:08 Review Received 16-Aug-2016 11:11:25 Reviewer Assignment Started 13-Aug-2016 06:21:08 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 11-Aug-2016 00:46:46 Reviewer Assignment Started 09-Aug-2016 18:21:33 Review Started 05-Aug-2016 03:51:43 First Reviewer Secured 05-Aug-2016 03:51:43 Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 05-Aug-2016 03:51:43 Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 03-Aug-2016 04:57:35 Potential Reviewers Selected 03-Aug-2016 04:57:31 Reviewer Assignment Started 01-Aug-2016 08:40:37 Securing Associate Editor 01-Aug-2016 08:40:37 Securing Editor 01-Aug-2016 08:40:36 Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed 01-Aug-2016 08:40:36 Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 01-Aug-2016 05:25:12 Securing Editor 01-Aug-2016 05:25:12 Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 01-Aug-2016 05:25:11 Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files 01-Aug-2016 04:38:11 File Conversion Completed 01-Aug-2016 04:38:11 Waiting for File Conversion 01-Aug-2016 04:36:53 File Conversion Completed 01-Aug-2016 04:36:20 Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 01-Aug-2016 04:17:53 File Conversion Completed 01-Aug-2016 02:17:23 最终的审稿结果，审稿人1还是依旧觉得我的文章很有信息，但建议再改改图的格式。审稿人2却拿我在response letter中使用的论据来堵我的嘴，依旧觉得我的文章没有任何物理上的新意，建议据稿。 Reviewer Comments: Reviewer #1 Evaluations: Significant Advance: Yes New Research: No Innovative Technology: No Scientific Advances: No Real World Applications: No English Correct: No Good Title: Yes Descriptive Abstract: Yes Good Figures: No Adequate References: Yes Reviewer #2 Evaluations: Significant Advance: No New Research: No Innovative Technology: No Scientific Advances: No Real World Applications: No English Correct: Yes Good Title: Yes Descriptive Abstract: Yes Good Figures: N/A Adequate References: N/A 但最终编辑权衡之后（应该就是那三天发生的事情），直接给我了接收的结果！ 不管怎样，前前后后历时87天的文章终于被接收了，此间有惊有喜！并且感觉到了JAP主编们的真诚与专业度，实在让人佩服！ 也希望这一老牌物理杂志以后越来越好！科研之路不易，大家且行且珍惜！ |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
308求调剂
已经有4人回复
-
NSFC申报书里申请人简历中代表性论著还需要在申报书最后的附件里面再上传一遍吗
已经有14人回复
-
材料与化工一志愿南昌大学327求调剂推荐
已经有6人回复
-
化学调剂0703
已经有7人回复
-
327求调剂
已经有11人回复
-
调剂
已经有8人回复
-
梁成伟老师课题组欢迎你的加入
已经有7人回复
-
伙伴们，祝我生日快乐吧
已经有24人回复
-
中科院材料273求调剂
已经有3人回复
-
材料工程专硕274一志愿211求调剂
已经有5人回复
小达达达
银虫 (正式写手)
- PC-EPI: 1
- 应助: 0 (幼儿园)
- 金币: 1820.8
- 散金: 100
- 红花: 3
- 帖子: 554
- 在线: 194.5小时
- 虫号: 2169860
- 注册: 2012-12-06
- 性别: GG
- 专业: 电路与系统
9楼2016-09-04 16:55:19
3楼2016-09-03 22:22:18
4楼2016-09-04 00:13:14
5楼2016-09-04 00:52:36
20