24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

本帖产生 1 个 PC-EPI ，点击这里进行查看

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

小达达达

银虫 (正式写手)

PC-EPI: 1
应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 1820.8
散金: 100
红花: 3
帖子: 554
在线: 194.5小时
虫号: 2169860
注册: 2012-12-06
性别: GG
专业: 电路与系统

[交流] 前后历经仨月，终于第二篇JAP被接收！

首先为虫友们贴出文章审稿的过程，这篇文章是我这半年的一个结晶之作，选择投JAP也是因为它在我们领域受众很广，影响力不错。而且我前一篇文章从投稿JAP到最终接收只花了一个月的时间：
Revised Manuscript Received from Author 01-Aug-2016 02:16:47
Waiting for Revised Manuscript from Author 15-Jul-2016 16:02:54
Decision Sent to Author 15-Jul-2016 16:02:54
Decision Letter Being Prepared 15-Jul-2016 15:42:12
Associate Editor Decision Completed 15-Jul-2016 15:42:12
Associate Editor Decision Started 13-Jul-2016 18:36:04
All Reviews Received 13-Jul-2016 18:36:04
Review Received 13-Jul-2016 18:36:04
All Reviewers Secured 04-Jul-2016 17:21:49
Review Started 04-Jul-2016 17:21:48
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 04-Jul-2016 17:21:48
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 04-Jul-2016 17:19:54
Potential Reviewers Selected 04-Jul-2016 17:19:47
Additional Reviewers Needed 04-Jul-2016 17:18:48
Reviewer Assignment Started 03-Jul-2016 06:20:57
Additional Reviewers Needed 03-Jul-2016 06:20:57
Potential Reviewer Declined to Review 03-Jul-2016 01:29:52
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 30-Jun-2016 07:22:35
Potential Reviewers Selected 30-Jun-2016 07:22:28
Additional Reviewers Needed 30-Jun-2016 07:22:07
Review Received 27-Jun-2016 03:34:37
Reviewer Assignment Started 24-Jun-2016 18:21:45
Additional Reviewers Needed 24-Jun-2016 18:21:45
Potential Reviewer Declined to Review 24-Jun-2016 14:43:52
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 22-Jun-2016 06:42:36
Potential Reviewers Selected 22-Jun-2016 06:42:27
Additional Reviewers Needed 22-Jun-2016 06:35:00
Reviewer Assignment Started 16-Jun-2016 12:20:58
Review Started 15-Jun-2016 05:56:35
First Reviewer Secured 15-Jun-2016 05:56:35
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 15-Jun-2016 05:56:35
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 14-Jun-2016 09:19:34
Potential Reviewers Selected 14-Jun-2016 09:19:28
Additional Reviewers Needed 14-Jun-2016 09:18:44
Reviewer Assignment Started 13-Jun-2016 12:21:43
Additional Reviewers Needed 13-Jun-2016 12:21:43
Potential Reviewer Declined to Review 13-Jun-2016 11:39:17
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 10-Jun-2016 06:10:35
Potential Reviewers Selected 10-Jun-2016 06:10:30
Additional Reviewers Needed 10-Jun-2016 06:08:02
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 10-Jun-2016 06:07:53
Potential Reviewers Selected 10-Jun-2016 06:07:49
Reviewer Assignment Started 08-Jun-2016 14:38:53
Securing Associate Editor 07-Jun-2016 12:37:57
Securing Editor 07-Jun-2016 12:37:57
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed 07-Jun-2016 12:37:57
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 07-Jun-2016 06:53:30
Securing Editor 07-Jun-2016 06:53:30
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 07-Jun-2016 06:53:29
Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files 07-Jun-2016 06:45:47
File Conversion Completed 07-Jun-2016 06:45:47
Waiting for File Conversion 07-Jun-2016 06:44:39
File Conversion Completed 07-Jun-2016 06:31:10
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 07-Jun-2016 06:27:54
File Conversion Completed 07-Jun-2016 03:31:56

一审被仨个审稿人据审有没有！！这对于经常刷系统看审稿进程的人儿的心脏是多么强烈的考验！！已经记不清，有多少次我深夜中惊醒，是梦到编辑由于找不到审稿人直接退稿......不得不佩服AIP的编辑，在1个月的时间内居然找了6个审稿人来约稿。
在经历38天的时间后，一审的结果终于下来了，结果很是令人忐忑：
两个审稿人，一个人在肯定我工作的同时，提出了一些格式上的小问题，原理上也提出了一些问题；另一个把我的工作指责了一番，各种层次的痛批，各种“No”,建议据稿。
但编辑最后给的是大修。

Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
Significant Advance: Yes
New Research: Yes
Innovative Technology: Yes
Scientific Advances: Yes
Real World Applications: Yes
English Correct: No
Good Title: Yes
Descriptive Abstract: Yes
Good Figures: No
Adequate References: Yes

Reviewer #2 Evaluations:
Significant Advance: No
New Research: No
Innovative Technology: No
Scientific Advances: No
Real World Applications: No
English Correct: No
Good Title: Yes
Descriptive Abstract: Yes
Good Figures: No
Adequate References: No

之后我针对这两个人的意见进行了细细的修改，三周之后，我上传了一个21页纸的response letter（近6000字），其中对于两位审稿人的意见回复使用了均等的篇幅。对第二个审稿人，我着重针对他的观点进行了反驳，认为他并没有理解我文中的真正意思。这个response letter我还是很满意的，毕竟把自己的意思全表述出来了，也对于自己很有自信！！
之后又进入了漫长的等待期。终于，在历经1个月之后在8.31时我终于看到了审稿状态变成了“Associate Editor Decision Completed”。但这才是真正折磨人的开始！！系统停留在Decision Letter Being Prepared足足有三天！！当时我就各种猜测编辑在干嘛，发个据稿或者接收有那么难吗？后来，当我看到最终的decision letter时，我知道了原因。

Stage Start Date
Manuscript Sent to Production 02-Sep-2016 20:00:52
Manuscript Ready for Production 02-Sep-2016 16:59:22
Decision Sent to Author 02-Sep-2016 16:59:22
Decision Letter Being Prepared 31-Aug-2016 03:58:29
Associate Editor Decision Completed 31-Aug-2016 03:58:29
Associate Editor Decision Started 30-Aug-2016 19:13:06
All Reviews Received 30-Aug-2016 19:13:06
Review Received 30-Aug-2016 19:13:06
All Reviewers Secured 30-Aug-2016 19:07:03
Review Started 30-Aug-2016 19:07:03
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 30-Aug-2016 19:07:03
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 29-Aug-2016 16:54:53
Reviewer Assignment Started 27-Aug-2016 06:21:02
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 25-Aug-2016 00:34:08
Review Received 16-Aug-2016 11:11:25
Reviewer Assignment Started 13-Aug-2016 06:21:08
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 11-Aug-2016 00:46:46
Reviewer Assignment Started 09-Aug-2016 18:21:33
Review Started 05-Aug-2016 03:51:43
First Reviewer Secured 05-Aug-2016 03:51:43
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 05-Aug-2016 03:51:43
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 03-Aug-2016 04:57:35
Potential Reviewers Selected 03-Aug-2016 04:57:31
Reviewer Assignment Started 01-Aug-2016 08:40:37
Securing Associate Editor 01-Aug-2016 08:40:37
Securing Editor 01-Aug-2016 08:40:36
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed 01-Aug-2016 08:40:36
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 01-Aug-2016 05:25:12
Securing Editor 01-Aug-2016 05:25:12
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 01-Aug-2016 05:25:11
Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files 01-Aug-2016 04:38:11
File Conversion Completed 01-Aug-2016 04:38:11
Waiting for File Conversion 01-Aug-2016 04:36:53
File Conversion Completed 01-Aug-2016 04:36:20
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 01-Aug-2016 04:17:53
File Conversion Completed 01-Aug-2016 02:17:23

最终的审稿结果，审稿人1还是依旧觉得我的文章很有信息，但建议再改改图的格式。审稿人2却拿我在response letter中使用的论据来堵我的嘴，依旧觉得我的文章没有任何物理上的新意，建议据稿。

Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
Significant Advance: Yes
New Research: No
Innovative Technology: No
Scientific Advances: No
Real World Applications: No
English Correct: No
Good Title: Yes
Descriptive Abstract: Yes
Good Figures: No
Adequate References: Yes

Reviewer #2 Evaluations:
Significant Advance: No
New Research: No
Innovative Technology: No
Scientific Advances: No
Real World Applications: No
English Correct: Yes
Good Title: Yes
Descriptive Abstract: Yes
Good Figures: N/A
Adequate References: N/A
但最终编辑权衡之后（应该就是那三天发生的事情），直接给我了接收的结果！
不管怎样，前前后后历时87天的文章终于被接收了，此间有惊有喜！并且感觉到了JAP主编们的真诚与专业度，实在让人佩服！
也希望这一老牌物理杂志以后越来越好！科研之路不易，大家且行且珍惜！

回复此楼