24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

【悬赏金币】回答本帖问题，作者faye-yu将赠送您 20 个金币

faye-yu

新虫 (小有名气)

应助: 1 (幼儿园)
金币: 1859.5
散金: 140
红花: 2
帖子: 253
在线: 94.5小时
虫号: 3141219
注册: 2014-04-16
专业: 其他无机非金属材料

[求助] SCI：journal of testing and evaluation遇到大修

请投过这个刊物的牛人们来帮助我一下，这些问题是什么意思？

以下六点是三位审稿人分别都问到的问题，区别在于问号后面的选项：有的是mandatory revision；有的是accept；有的是optional revisions；有的是reject。这到底是什么意思？
1.Contribution: Does the paper contribute to the permanent literature or to the immediate interests of the technical community? :M - Mandatory Revisions
2. Non-Commercial: Are all descriptions of commercial products, or their use, objective and not presented in an advertising manner? : A- Accept as is （O - Optional Revisions ）Please elaborate if necessary:
3. Communication: Is the paper acceptable in literary form and structure, continuity of thought, and logical development? : M - Mandatory Revisions （A- Accept as is）（R - Reject ）Please elaborate if necessary:
这一条是三位审稿人的三种态度：mandatory、accept和reject 都占齐了。
4. Not Previously Published: It is important that the substance of the paper shall not have been published elsewhere unless the paper is clearly defined as a review paper. Does the paper meet this requirement? : A- Accept as is （O - Optional Revisions）Please elaborate if necessary:
5. Succinctness: Is the paper including the title concise yet thorough? If condensation is required, please specify exactly what material is extraneous?: A- Accept as is （O - Optional Revisions）Please elaborate if necessary:
6. Reproducible Results: Are the material tested, the testing conditions, and the test results sufficiently described to permit other investigators to check the procedures and conclusions?: O - Optional Revisions （A- Accept as is ）（M - Mandatory Revisions ）Please elaborate if necessary:
这一条也是三位审稿人的三种态度：optional、accept和mandatory都占齐了。@Monash2011

回复此楼