24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

stormxuhao

至尊木虫 (知名作家)

应助: 176 (高中生)
贵宾: 2.445
金币: 15395
散金: 28663
红花: 95
沙发: 11
帖子: 8257
在线: 1086.4小时
虫号: 165633
注册: 2006-01-13
性别: GG
专业: 污染控制化学

[交流] 刚刚给Chemosphere审稿，看看期刊对于文章的要求。已有1人参与

今天刚刚给Chemosphere审稿，在填审稿意见的时候，发现给编辑的意见框里面有下面这样的一些选择题，很有意思。贴出来供各位参考，从中也能够看出杂志和编辑对于文章的什么点更看重。

[Y = yes; N = no; H = high; M = medium; L = low]

A Is this topic

1 suitable for the journal? Y
2 of broad international interest? Y
3 significant? Y
4 novel?  Y

Please explain your answers to items A1-4 here briefly

B Clarity of objectives: H
C Quality of methods/correctness of mathematics:  L
D Quality of data: M
E Validity of assumptions and analyses: H
F Extent to which the interpretations/conclusions are supported by the data: H
G Overall significance of this work: M

H Is this paper
1 properly organized? Y
2 to the point/concise? Y
3 written clearly using correct grammar and syntax? Y
I Are the approach, results and conclusions intelligible from the abstract alone? Y
J Is the title informative and a reflection of the content? Y
K Are the illustrations/tables
1 useful and all necessary? Y
2 of good quality? Y
L Is the referencing relevant, up to date and accessible? Y
M Are the keywords (if provided) appropriate and complete? Y
N Overall quality of the work:  M

Please note that your recommendation and reviewer report are expected to cover the Highlights and Graphical Abstract if submitted with the manuscript.

回复此楼