24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

F_Shaw

捐助贵宾 (著名写手)

应助: 95 (初中生)
金币: 1141.8
散金: 925
红花: 53
帖子: 1427
在线: 381.2小时
虫号: 1257528
注册: 2011-04-07
性别: GG
专业: 石油、天然气地质学

[交流] 投稿3天后直接显示minor revision，神马情况！已有26人参与

1.这本杂志不是收费期刊，IF1.38，在地学期刊里不算很低。有虫友担心我被骗钱，谢谢大家关心！
2.有些虫友说，receive只代表收到稿件，而且Comments里也说了英语润色达到要求之后才能送审，但是Elsevier系统里的的确确显示稿件状态为minor revision，难道送审之前也会出现这状态。
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
帮师弟投的稿件，投稿3天后直接显示minor revison，神马情况！
难道我人品大爆发了？！
下面是编辑的信(XXX, Editors decision, revise ):
Dear Dr. XXX,

I can now inform you that the reviewers and editor have evaluated the manuscript "xxxxxx" (Dr. xxxxx). I am pleased to say that it has been favourably received and publication with minor revision is recommended (see below and on https://ees.elsevier.com/aes/).

Please consider the reviews to see if revision would be feasible. To facilitate further review, add line numbers in the text of your manuscript. Should you wish to resubmit you should explain how and where (i.e. by giving line numbers) each point of the reviewers' comments has been incorporated. For this, use submission item "Revision
Notes" when uploading your revision. Also, indicate the changes in an annotated version of the revised manuscript (submission item "Revision, changes marked"

. Please follow the order "Revision Notes", "Revision, changes marked", "Manuscript", etc.
If you choose to revise your manuscript it will be due by
01 Aug 2015.

Should you disagree with any part of the reviews, please explain why.

Please strictly follow the formatting requirements as presented in the Guide for Authors.
但奇怪的是，后面的审稿意见只有下面的内容，好像意思是说文章英语水平还没有达到审稿要求，还没有进入审稿流程？到底是什么情况？另外Elsevier里的状态又的确是minor revision？求大侠指教！
COMMENTS FROM EDITORS AND REVIEWERS

EDITOR'S COMMENTS (PATRICK ERIKSSON, 17.06.2015) THIS IS AN INTERESTING PAPER FOR THE JAES. ALL IT NEEDS BEFORE GOING TO REVIEW IS AN ENGLISH EDIT, PLEASE - THE PAPER IS NOT BADLY WRITTEN BUT THE ENGLISH IS NOT QUITE UP TO REVIEW STANDARD. MANY THANKS!

[ Last edited by F_Shaw on 2015-6-18 at 10:04 ]

回复此楼