±±¾©Ê¯ÓÍ»¯¹¤Ñ§Ôº2026ÄêÑо¿ÉúÕÐÉú½ÓÊÕµ÷¼Á¹«¸æ
²é¿´: 3044  |  »Ø¸´: 25

wuwuxuxu

Í­³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

[ÇóÖú] ÊDz»ÊDZ»SCI¼ÓÃÁË?Äܲ»Äܰïæ¿´¿´Õâ¸öÐÞ¸ÄÒâ¼û£¬ºÃ¸ÄÂð£¿Ð»Ð»À²£¡£¡

Dear Research of Routing Protocol for Wireless Sensor N XXX

We have received the reports from our advisors on your manuscript, "Research of Routing Protocol for Wireless Sensor Network in Coal Mine Goaf", submitted to
Wireless Personal Communications

Based on the advice received, I have decided that your manuscript can be accepted for publication after you have carried out the corrections as suggested by the reviewer(s).

Attached, please find the reviewers' comments for your perusal.

"If one or more reviewers have uploaded files related to their reviews, these files can be accessed by clicking on this link:



Alternatively, the file(s) can be downloaded from your main menu by clicking on 'View Reviewer Attachments'.

Please note that this link will not be available when there are no reviewer attachments."



5Comments for the Author:

Reviewer #1: Suggestions for improvements:
1-        Title is suggested to be changed as the "research in routing protocol for wireless sensor network in Coal Mine Goaf" is very general title and not reflecting specific research work proposed in this paper.  Suggested title " proposal for efficient routing protocol for wireless sensor network in Coal Mine Goaf"
2-        Abstract should highlight more the significance of the work in comparison with finding from literature to give the sense of research gap highlighted.
3-        Please consider more nearest research and most updated ones as the author almost 85% depends on papers from 2007 and beyond and some of them chinese language.
4-        Table-2 summarizing the processes of proposed algorithm is better to be represented in flowchart reflecting the proposed author methodologies.
5-        Some sentences are ambiguous and should be considered in better phrasing for English paper publication. Example: "As coal mine goaf cannot be accessed by man".
6-        Suggestions to evaluate the proposed algorithm with similar near-field algorithms in literature in term of algorithm complexity and computational cost.



Reviewer #2: Authors have proposed a protocol  named  USEB-CMF  to improve the safety of the monitoring system of coal mines. However paper has some issues: -
1) Some more related work should be included.
2) Architecture should be explained in more detail.
3) Algorithm/Pseudo code is not properly written and explained.
4) Some more work should be done for journal paper.  


Reviewer #3: Overall paper need to proof read for errors e.g.  "transmission powder" in section 2 and
"COMPTE_MSG" in algorithm 1
»Ø¸´´ËÂ¥

» ²ÂÄãϲ»¶

» ±¾Ö÷ÌâÏà¹Ø¼ÛÖµÌùÍÆ¼ö£¬¶ÔÄúͬÑùÓаïÖú:

Ãæ³¯´óº££¬´ºÅ¯»¨¿ª
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
»ØÌûÖ§³Ö ( ÏÔʾ֧³Ö¶È×î¸ßµÄǰ 50 Ãû )

dong1059

ľ³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
ÊÇÐ޸ĺó½ÓÊÕ¡£»»¾ä»°Ëµ£ºÄãÄܰ´ÕÕÉó¸åÈ˵ÄÒâ¼ûºÃºÃÐ޸쬾ÍÄܽÓÊÕÁË£»µ«ÊÇÄã²»°´Éó¸åÈ˵ÄÒâ¼û¸Ä£¬Êǻᱯ¾çµÄ¡£µ«ÕûÌåÒâ¼ûÊÇÕýÃæ»ý¼«µÄ¡£Â¥Ö÷ºÃºÃ¼ÓÓÍ£¬ÖðÌõ»Ø¸´Éó¸åÈËÒâ¼û¡£×£Ò»ÇÐ˳Àû¡£
11Â¥2013-11-22 09:16:08
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

dancy1987

ľ³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

°´ÕÕÉó¸åÈËÒ»µÄÒâ¼ûÖðÌõÐ޸Ġ ¿ÉÊÇÃ²ËÆ¶þÈýµÄÒâ¼ûÓÐЩÁýͳ  ËùÒÔ»¹ÊÇÕë¶ÔÐÔ¸ÄÏ ¸Ð¾õ±à¼­ÒѾ­ÇãÏòÓÚ½ÓÊÜ  ËùÒÔ×¥½ô¸Ä°É£¡

[ ·¢×ÔСľ³æ¿Í»§¶Ë ]

» ±¾ÌûÒÑ»ñµÃµÄºì»¨£¨×îÐÂ10¶ä£©

×öÒ»¸öÓÐÐÄÈË£¡
23Â¥2013-11-24 01:01:36
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
ÆÕͨ»ØÌû

615780236

½û³æ (ÖªÃû×÷¼Ò)

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
±¾ÌûÄÚÈݱ»ÆÁ±Î

2Â¥2013-11-21 23:26:08
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

wuwuxuxu

Í­³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

Ãæ³¯´óº££¬´ºÅ¯»¨¿ª
3Â¥2013-11-21 23:26:15
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

mythlo

ľ³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
ÎÄÕ»ù±¾ÉϽÓÊÜÁË£¬µ«ÊÇÒ²ÐèÒªÈÏÕæ¸Äһϣ¬¹§Ï²°¡
4Â¥2013-11-22 00:41:27
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

guojiahu

½û³æ (ÖªÃû×÷¼Ò)

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
±¾ÌûÄÚÈݱ»ÆÁ±Î

5Â¥2013-11-22 00:46:30
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

wenshengping853

ÖÁ×ðľ³æ (ÎÄ̳¾«Ó¢)

¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
¹§Ï²Â¥Ö÷ ÎÄÕ ¿ìÒª½ÓÊÜÁË ºÃºÃ¸Ä
6Â¥2013-11-22 01:11:45
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

jinwei331

ÖÁ×ðľ³æ (ÎÄ̳¾«Ó¢)

¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
Ó¦¸ÃÊÇ»ù±¾Â¼ÓõĽÚ×࣬ºÃºÃ°´ÒªÇóÐ޸ġ£
7Â¥2013-11-22 06:31:27
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

vincent.kahn

Ìú³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
ÊôÓÚ´óÐÞ°É£¬Â¥Ö÷¼ÓÓͰÉ

[ ·¢×ÔСľ³æ¿Í»§¶Ë ]
¿ÆÑÐÐèÒª½»Á÷
8Â¥2013-11-22 08:06:46
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

jy01779652

ľ³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

¡¾´ð°¸¡¿Ó¦Öú»ØÌû

¸Ðл²ÎÓ룬ӦÖúÖ¸Êý +1
¹§Ï²Äã¡£¡£¡£Õâ¸öÓ¦¸ÃÊǺúÃÐ޺ûù±¾ÉϾͿÉÒÔ±»Â¼ÓÃÁË¡£¡£¡£ÕæÊÇÏÛĽÄã°¡¡£¡£¹§Ï²¹§Ï²
9Â¥2013-11-22 08:23:51
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

toughxu

ľ³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

¹§Ï²£¬ËãÊÇСÐÞ£¬¶øÇÒÃ÷È·¸æËßÄãÐ޸ĺó½ÓÊÕ£¬²»¹ý»¹Òª×ÐϸÐ޸ġ£
10Â¥2013-11-22 08:46:01
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
Ïà¹Ø°æ¿éÌø×ª ÎÒÒª¶©ÔÄÂ¥Ö÷ wuwuxuxu µÄÖ÷Ìâ¸üÐÂ
×î¾ßÈËÆøÈÈÌûÍÆ¼ö [²é¿´È«²¿] ×÷Õß »Ø/¿´ ×îºó·¢±í
[¿¼ÑÐ] 22408 359·Öµ÷¼Á +4 Qshers 2026-03-27 5/250 2026-03-28 21:26 by zhq0425
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085602 »¯¹¤×¨Ë¶ 338·Ö Çóµ÷¼Á +12 ·³ÕСç÷ 2026-03-27 12/600 2026-03-28 15:41 by L135790
[¿¼ÑÐ] Ò»Ö¾Ô¸±±¾©¹¤Òµ´óѧ£¬324·ÖÇóµ÷¼Á +4 Áã°Ë# 2026-03-28 4/200 2026-03-28 15:01 by 17865157980
[¿¼ÑÐ] 291Çóµ÷¼Á +15 hhhhxn.. 2026-03-23 21/1050 2026-03-28 11:26 by self2008
[¿¼ÑÐ] 292Çóµ÷¼Á +14 ¶ì¶ì¶ì¶î¶î¶î¶î¶ 2026-03-25 15/750 2026-03-28 08:45 by WYUMater
[¿¼ÑÐ] 311Çóµ÷¼Á +3 Ï£ÍûÉϰ¶°¢Ð¡Ñî 2026-03-23 3/150 2026-03-28 07:57 by ÈÈÇéɳĮ
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085404Çóµ÷¼Á£¬×Ü·Ö309£¬±¾¿Æ¾­Àú½ÏΪ·á¸» +4 À´²Æaa 2026-03-25 4/200 2026-03-28 07:41 by °ô°ôÇòÊÖ
[¿¼ÑÐ] ÕÅ·¼Ãú-Öйúũҵ´óѧ-»·¾³¹¤³Ìר˶-298 +4 ÊÖ»úÓû§ 2026-03-26 4/200 2026-03-28 07:17 by mmm just
[¿¼ÑÐ] 331»·¾³¿ÆÑ§Ó빤³ÌÇóµ÷¼Á +3 ìÚÈ»ºÃÔËÆø 2026-03-27 3/150 2026-03-28 04:11 by fmesaito
[¿¼ÑÐ] 330Ò»Ö¾Ô¸Öйúº£Ñó´óѧ »¯Ñ§¹¤³Ì 085602 ÓжÁ²©ÒâÔ¸ Çóµ÷¼Á +3 wywy.. 2026-03-27 4/200 2026-03-28 03:32 by fmesaito
[¿¼ÑÐ] 265Çóµ÷¼Á +8 Сľ³æ085600 2026-03-27 8/400 2026-03-27 22:16 by Î޼ʵIJÝÔ­
[¿¼ÑÐ] 285Çóµ÷¼Á +4 AZMK 2026-03-27 7/350 2026-03-27 20:59 by AZMK
[¿¼ÑÐ] 274Çóµ÷¼Á +17 ¹Ë¾ÅóÏҪǫÐé 2026-03-24 23/1150 2026-03-27 15:16 by caszguilin
[¿¼ÑÐ] 279 ·Ö Çóµ÷¼Á +4 ˯¸öºÃ¾õ_16 2026-03-24 4/200 2026-03-27 15:05 by ×íÔÚ·çÀï
[¿¼ÑÐ] 085601 ²ÄÁϹ¤³Ì 313·Ö Çóµ÷¼Á +5 Ong3 2026-03-27 5/250 2026-03-27 12:24 by goldfish51
[¿¼ÑÐ] 359Çóµ÷¼Á +4 ÍõÁ˸öéª 2026-03-25 4/200 2026-03-27 08:43 by ²»³Ôô~µÄ؈
[¿¼ÑÐ] 318Çóµ÷¼Á +3 plumÀî×Ó 2026-03-23 3/150 2026-03-25 09:42 by ÎíÉ¢ºóÏàÓölc
[¿¼ÑÐ] ÉϺ£µçÁ¦´óѧ²ÄÁÏ·À»¤ÓëвÄÁÏÖØµãʵÑéÊÒÕÐÊÕµ÷¼ÁÑо¿Éú£¨²ÄÁÏ¡¢»¯Ñ§¡¢µç»¯Ñ§£¬»·¾³£© +4 ÎÒ°®Ñ§µç³Ø 2026-03-23 4/200 2026-03-25 00:59 by 1027_324
[¿¼ÑÐ] 277·ÖÇóµ÷¼Á£¬¿çµ÷²ÄÁÏ +3 ¿¼Ñе÷¼Álxh 2026-03-24 3/150 2026-03-24 13:52 by JourneyLucky
[¿¼ÑÐ] 070300£¬Ò»Ö¾Ô¸±±º½320Çóµ÷¼Á +3 Jerry0216 2026-03-22 5/250 2026-03-23 09:16 by ¡£¡£ÌÃÌÃ
ÐÅÏ¢Ìáʾ
ÇëÌî´¦ÀíÒâ¼û