[交流] 申述信... 已有5人参与

最近投scripta mater. 被reject了。看了一下审稿人的意见，感觉这个审稿人不是我所研究领域的，遂起写了一篇申述信，不知道有没有用，但是感觉还是应该尝试一下，大家看看我怎么写可以吗？给点意见 Dear Prof.**, Our manuscript titled ** was submitted to Scripta Materialia and was rejected after sending out for review. We would like to thank the editor and the reviewer for giving us constructive suggestions which would help us in depth to improve the quality of the paper. However, we think there are no sufficient reasons in the decision letter for us to accept the conclusion and the reviewer seems to misunderstand the purpose of our study. Our paper is studying **. This is a significant aspect in the field of**. Some characteristics of Ti alloys under impact loading are completely different from those under conventional processing conditions, such as super plasticity, ultrafine grains and amorphization. The phase transformation of Ti alloys is really complex, and as regard to omega phase transformation, there are two types: althermal omega phase and isothermal omega phase. This paper is precisely observed the althermal omega phase transformation in Ti alloys during **. There are two innovations here: one is**for the first time and the other one is **. We believe that our investigation is a good work with scientific meaning on materials dynamic behavior and fit for the purpose of Scripta Materialia, although the evidences may be insufficient in our manuscript. The followings are our opinions toward to the reviewer comments. We really appreciate you if you can read it and have reconsideration towards our manuscript. Sincerely yours, ** [ Last edited by 江枫2008 on 2010-9-26 at 10:29 ]

回复此楼

» 收录本帖的淘帖专辑推荐

论文发表需用的各种模板

SCI论文攻略

xjjin

» 猜你喜欢

• 生物学308分求调剂（一志愿华东师大） 已经有3人回复
• 求调剂：一志愿：南京大学 专业：0705 总分320 ，本科985，四六级已过 已经有3人回复
• 环境工程 085701，267求调剂 已经有14人回复
• 308求调剂 已经有12人回复
• 求调剂：085600材料与化工，考材科基，总分319 已经有21人回复
• 311求调剂 已经有8人回复
• 294分080500材料科学与工程求调剂 已经有13人回复
• 288求调剂 一志愿哈工大 材料与化工 已经有19人回复
• 288资源与环境专硕求调剂，不限专业，有学上就行 已经有23人回复
• 一志愿085600中科院宁波所276分求调剂 已经有17人回复

高级回复