²é¿´: 1215  |  »Ø¸´: 6
µ±Ç°Ö÷ÌâÒѾ­´æµµ¡£

kqp1982

ľ³æ (ÖøÃûдÊÖ)

[½»Á÷] Ð޸ĺó¿É·ñÔÙͶJCIS£¿ÒÑÓÐ2È˲ÎÓë

Dear Dr. Tiandi,

Thank you for submitting your article to the Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. Unfortunately, based on the reviewer comments, we regret to inform you that we are unable to publish it. Due to the high demand for space within the pages of this Journal, we must decline a large portion of the manuscripts received.

The reviewer comments are summarized below.
Sincerely,



Reviewers' comments:


Reviewer #1: Recommendation: Reject.

Comments:


1.    The introduction part of the manuscript is very weak.

2.    There are plenty of publications on the topic, which have been not acknowledged in the references of the present manuscript.


3.    The authors do not show any motivation for the presented work.

4.    What I am missing right away going through this work what is the qualitatively and quantitatively new knowledge that the authors are seeking.

5.    Authors reported about low contact angle hysteresis and did not show any results on advancing/receding contact angles.

6.    Authors discussed about nano/micro level structures of fabricated coatings, however did not present any results on the values of surface roughness parameters.

7.     The explanation/discussion seems to me be not logic and not completed. Especially for this case, one should present roughness parameters values (roughness factor).

8.    The terminology used by authors is not always correct. For instance, in the Part 3.2 instead of "Surface Morphous" should be "surface morphology".

9.    There are many other experimental uncertainties.

In my opinion, the paper does not show any novelty, interesting discussions and suffers from many experimental and theoretical uncertainties.
This work does not satisfy the requirements and high level of the Journal of Colloid and Interface Science.


The English requires a throughout editing.

New physical insights or important experimental developments: Fair

Conclusions adequately supported by data: Fair

Clarity of presentation: Fair

Potential for scientific impact: Fair




Reviewer #2: This paper reported ......, which is important in the development of self-cleaning surface. I recommended it to be published on JCIS after some revision:
1.How about the stability and mechanical property of the coating film? Is it easy to peel off from the substrate? How about if we scrape it?
2.It seems from SEM images (Fig. 2) that the coating materials do not cover all the substrate, what will the water droplet change after it sitting longer on the surface? (time-dependent property)
3.The figure that shows the mechanism (Fig. 4) is too ideal.
»Ø¸´´ËÂ¥

» ÊÕ¼±¾ÌûµÄÌÔÌûר¼­ÍƼö

Ͷ¸åÐëÖª Biosorption

» ²ÂÄãϲ»¶

ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

xiaoguodong

½ð³æ (СÓÐÃûÆø)

¡ï
Сľ³æ(½ð±Ò+0.5):¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû½»Á÷
ÒòΪ´æÔÚÎÊÌâ½Ï¶à£¬Èç¹ûÂÛÎÄûÓдóµÄÌá¸ß£¬½¨Òé¿ÉÒÔ¸ÄͶÆäËûÔÓÖ¾ÊÔÊÔ---
2Â¥2010-03-25 18:08:08
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

lcljldx

½ð³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

¡ï
Сľ³æ(½ð±Ò+0.5):¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû½»Á÷
µ¢Îó²»±ØÒªµÄʱ¼ä£¬²»Öµ£¡
3Â¥2010-03-25 18:48:56
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

felicity6056

Ìú¸Ëľ³æ (ÖªÃû×÷¼Ò)

¡ï
Сľ³æ(½ð±Ò+0.5):¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû½»Á÷
¸ÄͶ±ðµÄ°É£¬ËäÈ»ÎÒÓÐһƪÊDZ»¾ÜºóÖØÐÂͶ¹ý¡£ÏÖÔÚ»¹ÔÚµÈÏûÏ¢¡£
4Â¥2010-03-25 19:31:48
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

liushu0226

ÖÁ×ðľ³æ (Ö°Òµ×÷¼Ò)

¡ï
Сľ³æ(½ð±Ò+0.5):¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû½»Á÷
µÚÒ»¸öÉó¸åÈ˾ܵúÜÇ¿Ó²£¬µÚ¶þ¸öÏ൱ÓÚÐÞ¸Äºó·¢±í¡£Èç¹ûÄܹ»²¹³äʵÑ飬´ó¸ÄÎÄÕµĻ°¿ÉÒÔÔÙͶÕâ¸öÔÓÖ¾¡£ÎÒÓÐһƪÎÄÕ±»¾Üºó£¬´ó¸ÄºóÔÙͶֱ½Ó¼ÓÃÁË£¬¹Ø¼üÔÚÓÚÄã¸ÄµÃºÃ»µ¡£
5Â¥2010-03-25 20:13:45
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

jwdxbjzh

ÖÁ×ðľ³æ (Ö°Òµ×÷¼Ò)

½¨Òé¸ÄͶ

¡ï
Сľ³æ(½ð±Ò+0.5):¸ø¸öºì°ü£¬Ð»Ð»»ØÌû½»Á÷
ÒÀÕÕÂ¥Ö÷µÄÇé¿ö£¬ÎÒ¸öÈ˽¨Òé°´ÕÕÉó¸åÈËÒâ¼û½øÐÐÐ޸ģ¬È»ºó¸ÄͶËü¿¯¡£ÒòΪÎÊÌâºÍ¾Ü¸å¶¼ºÜÃ÷ÏԵرíʾÄãµÄÎÄÕ²»ÊÊÒË·¢±í¡£ÎÒ2007ÄêÔڸÿ¯·¢±í¹ýһƪÂÛÎÄ£¬Á½¸öÉó¸åÈ˶¼½¨Òé·¢±í£¬Ö»ÊÇÌáÁËһЩСÎÊÌâ¡£¼ûÏÂÃ棺

Reviewers' comments:

Thank you for submitting your nice manuscript JCIS-06-1889 to JCIS. It is clearly of potential interest to JCIS readers.

Before passing on to the review stage I am asking you to consider the possibility of making a few (modest) changes, listed below as points 1 and 2.

I see the purpose of these changes to make the papers that are eventually published in JCIS concise and interesting to the readership, as well as being scientifically satisfying: this will help attract readers to learn about your research.  I trust you understand the motivation for this request, which is primarily so that your research ideas receive as wide an audience as possible.

I guarantee that your revision will be promptly dealt with by our JCIS staff in Bristol.

Thank you for submitting your nice work to JCIS.

Julian Eastoe

Editorial comments

1. Supply the names and e-mail contact details of five potential reviewers, who are NOT also members of the JCIS board.  The names of board members can be found at

http://www.elsevier.com/wps/find ... 2861/editorialboard


2. The main paper does not contain any of the kinetic data, which has in fact been included in supporting material. Please could you include one or two key figures in the revised main manuscript, by moving them from supporting materials into the main paper.  This would give the readership a much clearer idea of how the conclusions have been arrived at. It is NOT my suggestion to considerably lengthen the paper, this current length seems fine, but adding some important experimental data will strengthen the main manuscript and improve the scientific credibility.
jwd
6Â¥2010-04-04 22:19:46
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû

luoxianyang

Òø³æ (ÕýʽдÊÖ)

½¨ÒéÂ¥Ö÷¸ÄͶÆäËüÔÓÖ¾£¬²»ÒªÀË·Ñʱ¼ä
7Â¥2010-04-06 12:02:15
ÒÑÔÄ   »Ø¸´´ËÂ¥   ¹Ø×¢TA ¸øTA·¢ÏûÏ¢ ËÍTAºì»¨ TAµÄ»ØÌû
Ïà¹Ø°æ¿éÌøת ÎÒÒª¶©ÔÄÂ¥Ö÷ kqp1982 µÄÖ÷Ìâ¸üÐÂ
×î¾ßÈËÆøÈÈÌûÍƼö [²é¿´È«²¿] ×÷Õß »Ø/¿´ ×îºó·¢±í
[»ù½ðÉêÇë] 2025ÃæÉÏÔ¤Ëã¶àÉÙºÏÊÊ +5 гÇ×ÓÔø 2025-02-16 8/400 2025-02-16 22:54 by гÇ×ÓÔø
[˶²©¼ÒÔ°] ¸Ã²»¸ÃÌṩÊý¾Ý +17 lupo140155 2025-02-12 33/1650 2025-02-16 20:55 by ÁÁÁÁ¼ÓÓÍ
[»ù½ðÉêÇë] ÃæÉÏÏîÄ¿Ä£°åµÄÁ¢ÏîÒÀ¾ÝÇ°ÃæµÄµÚÒ»¸ö»ÆÉ«¿òÊǸÉÂïÓÃµÄ +12 bangkuday 2025-02-14 17/850 2025-02-16 20:22 by brblmd
[˶²©¼ÒÔ°] É격-²©µ¼ÎÊÎÒÂÛÎűÏ×ÎÊÌâ +6 CG-KY 2025-02-15 11/550 2025-02-16 20:12 by Andy_124
[˶²©¼ÒÔ°] É격-²©µ¼Í¨¹ýÓʼþѯÎÊÎÊÌâ +4 CG-KY 2025-02-16 4/200 2025-02-16 19:27 by white7wine
[˶²©¼ÒÔ°] »¤ÀíѧÇóÈ«Ö°¿ÆÑÐÖúÀí/¿ÆÑÐʵϰ»ú»á +4 LIUTINGXIN 2025-02-15 4/200 2025-02-16 18:36 by baiboxie
[¿¼ÑÐ] ¿¼ÑÐÕÐÉú +10 ³Ì³¤£¨zhang£© 2025-02-14 20/1000 2025-02-16 17:35 by ¾ÅÈýhs
[¿¼²©] ²©Ê¿ÉêÇë +8 ³ÃÔçÉÏ°¶ 2025-02-10 11/550 2025-02-16 15:42 by lzg96wl
[ÂÛÎÄͶ¸å] ¹§Ï²×Ô¼ºÁ©ÆªºËÐÄÂÛÎÄÈ«ÖУ¡£¡£¡ +18 a614822361 2025-02-13 21/1050 2025-02-16 14:51 by a614822361
[˶²©¼ÒÔ°] (³£ÄêÓÐЧ)ÖÐÍâÖªÃû¸ßУ(QSÅÅÃûÇ°3)ÁªÅà - ÕÐļ´óÄ£Ðͼ°Ç¿»¯Ñ§Ï°²©Ê¿ÉúºÍ²©Ê¿ºó +5 cowhorce 2025-02-16 5/250 2025-02-16 14:40 by sji@987
[Óлú½»Á÷] Ñ°ÕÒ²ÄÁÏ¡¢Ò½Ò©¡¢ÉúÎïµÈµÈÀà±ðÓлú·Ö×Ӻϳɶ¨ÖÆ +6 ЦÆðÀ´ÕæºÃ¿´°¡ 2025-02-11 10/500 2025-02-16 00:30 by bringcool
[»ù½ðÉêÇë] ÐÄ̬±ÀÁË£¡£¡£¡ +3 20081002 2025-02-13 11/550 2025-02-15 17:03 by AZURESKY1999
[ÂÛÎÄͶ¸å] Ͷ¸åÓöµ½technical screening 39+3 ÇáÃèʱ¹âl 2025-02-14 5/250 2025-02-15 16:55 by lzg96wl
[¿¼ÑÐ] 320Çóµ÷¼Á +3 ÓÀ²»ÑÔÆúµÄС͸à 2025-02-12 3/150 2025-02-15 10:47 by д´úÂëµÄcoder
[¿¼ÑÐ] ±±¾©ÐÅÏ¢¿Æ¼¼´óѧ08¹¤Ñ§×¨Òµ¶à¸ö·½ÏòÓе÷¼Áȱ¶î +3 bxklm 2025-02-11 3/150 2025-02-14 22:44 by ÉîÏïҹè
[ÂÛÎÄͶ¸å] SCIÐÞ¸ÄÒâ¼ûÉêÇëÑÓÆÚ,·¢Óʼþ¸±Ö÷±àͬÒâ,µ«ÊÇϵͳÀïÌύʱ¼äûÓиıä,Ôõô°ì 10+4 ÀîÅôlp 2025-02-10 4/200 2025-02-14 15:29 by sherry_88
[ÂÛÎÄͶ¸å] ¶Ô±à¼­µÄ»Ø¸´ 5+4 É°ÌÇÈýÈý 2025-02-10 4/200 2025-02-14 15:26 by sherry_88
[¿¼ÑÐ] 357Çóµ÷¼Á +3 ³ÇÏçÖ®±ð 2025-02-12 7/350 2025-02-12 21:05 by l?h?j
[»ù½ðÉêÇë] ÃÀ¹úNSF½«²Ã³·50%Ô±¹¤¡¢NIH×ÊÖú±»ÔÝÍ££¬µ«¼ÌÐøÖ§³ÖDARPA¾ü¹¤Ñо¿ +4 zju2000 2025-02-10 5/250 2025-02-12 01:37 by zju2000
[¿¼ÑÐ] 389Çóµ÷¼Á +6 erzhudou 2025-02-10 6/300 2025-02-11 18:50 by Andy_124
ÐÅÏ¢Ìáʾ
ÇëÌî´¦ÀíÒâ¼û