24小时热门版块排行榜

返回列表

当前只显示满足指定条件的回帖，点击这里查看本话题的所有回帖

flysmiles

铁虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 378.8
散金: 124
帖子: 166
在线: 119.3小时
虫号: 2626070
注册: 2013-08-31
专业: 海洋工程

[求助] 有已经发表了SCI文章的硕士以及博士（最好是控制研究方向的）请进，谢谢。已有1人参与

楼主是工科博士，偏控制方向。楼主的一篇SCI出了点问题，具体是这样的：一审两个审稿人A（对文章评价比较高也比较感兴趣，给的意见是小修，并提了10个问题）,审稿人B（对文章评价还行，给了大修，并提了4个问题）。
楼主修好后最近意见返回，A审稿人很满意同意发表，B审稿人拒稿，编辑最后给了拒稿，可能编辑也觉得有点冤，最后编辑说“One reviewer is opposite to the publication. I advise you to take into account his remarks to submit your paper again.”
看网上的像我这种情况的一般都录用了，请问我该怎么办？重新投稿不知道又要花多久，真心难受。
我分析原因主要是楼主在回答审稿人的问题的时候说了下面的两条（第一个审稿人都觉得没有什么问题，然后第二个审稿人觉得有问题），具体如下：
①The classical control theory involves single input and single output system which is powerless when it comes to the multiple input and multiple output system.
②The classical control theory is also named as the conventional control theory. The research object of the classical control theory is the automatic control system of single input and single output, especially the linear system, which is powerless as to the multiple input and multiple output system. However, the AUV in our manuscript is a multiple input and multiple output under-actuated system. Therefore, the conventional control theory will be difficult and cannot to be used.
下面是审稿人B的回复，拒稿的原因基本就出在了这里。
In the responses to the comments, the authors declare that conventional control theory cannot be used to control the underactuated AUV systems. The authors only focus on the conventional linear controllers, such as PID and PD for the single input and single output linear systems. However, the general nonlinear controllers for multi-input and multi-output nonlinear systems have not been taken into consideration. As we know, the commonly used control techniques for underactuated nonlinear systems are Lyapunov-based nonlinear controllers, rather than linear controller based on local approximate linearization. The limitations of approximate linearization include local controllability and invalidation for large initial errors. In addition, the linearizable regions of the system model cannot be quantitatively determined. By contrast, it has a great potential to design a nonlinear controller for trajectory tracking of the AUVs, which can achieve better tracking performances. Thus, from the viewpoint of the reviewer, the controller designed in this paper has many limitations for applications, at least the superiority and novelty of the work have not been well presented.
我想问的是审稿人有没有曲解我的意思，或者我的说法存在什么问题，审稿人的回复有问题吗？谢谢。

回复此楼

» 猜你喜欢

收到国自然专家邀请后几年才会有本子送过来评已经有4人回复
考博已经有5人回复
26年申博自荐-计算机视觉已经有4人回复
药化及相关博士的申请已经有3人回复
一篇MDPI论文改变了学习工作和生活已经有4人回复
一个化合物的合成路线：CAS:367929-02-0 名称：8β-乙烯基雌二醇已经有4人回复
中国地质大学（北京）博士招生补录，数理学院材料科学与工程专业和材料与化工专业已经有3人回复

» 本主题相关价值贴推荐，对您同样有帮助:

SCI 论文写作和发表 Q & A 已经有58人回复
SCI杂志投稿经验已经有24人回复
Elsevier(SCI) 投稿要求翻译总结已经有28人回复
SCI论文写作实例点评和时态问题已经有254人回复

1楼 2016-03-03 23:12:20

已阅回复此楼关注TA 给TA发消息送TA红花 TA的回帖

flysmiles

铁虫 (小有名气)

应助: 0 (幼儿园)
金币: 378.8
散金: 124
帖子: 166
在线: 119.3小时
虫号: 2626070
注册: 2013-08-31
专业: 海洋工程

引用回帖:

2脗楼: Originally posted by zxm_232004 at 2016-03-03 23:22:47
脳卯潞贸脕陆戮盲禄掳脳脨脧赂露脕露脕拢卢脢脟脣碌脛茫碌脛路陆路篓脛脩脪脭脫娄脫脙拢卢脪脭录掳麓麓脨脗虏禄鹿禄拢卢脟掳脙忙脢脟脭脷掳茂脛茫脌铆脣录脗路拢卢虏鹿驴脦拢卢脣霉脪脭脛茫脰禄脛脺脳脨脧赂碌脛陆芒戮枚脮芒脕陆赂枚脦脢脤芒拢卢脭脵脥露拢卢脫娄赂脙脦脢脤芒虏禄麓贸拢卢脰禄脢脟脫脰碌脙脮脹脤脷脪禄卤茅

赂脨戮玫脡贸赂氓脠脣潞脥脦脪脭脷赂脜脛卯碌脛路脰路篓脡脧脙忙驴脡脛脺陆脟露脠虏禄脥卢拢卢脪虏驴脡脛脺脡贸赂氓脠脣B脟煤陆芒脕脣脦脪碌脛脪芒脣录拢卢脛煤戮玫碌脙赂酶卤脿录颅路垄脫脢录镁脡锚脣脽驴脡脪脭脗冒拢驴脨禄脨禄隆拢