Please accept our apologies for the delay in returning a recommendation on your manuscript.
We are sorry to inform you that your manuscript in its present form is not suitable for publication in Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A. This decision has been based on the report of the reviewers, a copy of which is enclosed.
If you should decide that, despite this rejection, you would like to submit a revised paper to Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A, we will be glad to consider your new paper for publication. However, your accompanying letter of transmittal should indicate explicitly how you have dealt with each of the reviewers' comments, so that the original problems pointed out by the reviewers are not repeated in the new manuscript.
Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A