| 查看: 955 | 回复: 17 | |||
[交流]
大家看看重投还有希望吗 小白第一次投稿 投的access
|
|||
|
Reviewer: 1 Recommendation: Reject (updates required before resubmission) Comments: The authors proposed a face super-resolution (FSR) network based on a gradient information compensation module. This paper believes that the gradient information is beneficial to the performance of FSR, and designed a special module to extract the gradient information of the feature maps. I think this article is interesting and looks good, but there are still some issues that need to be revised (unordered): (1) In order to prove the effectiveness of the proposed method, the authors conducted a series of ablation studies. However, ablation research must follow some principles. For example, when authors prove that their GRBs are beneficial to improve the performance of the network, they should not prove by reducing the number of GRBs. Because it is not clear whether the performance loss is due to the reduction in the number of parameters or the lack of gradient information. Considering that the gradient layer is an artificial design without any learnable parameters, and its computational complexity is negligible. So it seems more reasonable to delete the gradient layer directly and observe the network performance. (2) The author declares "Since only the test code of FSRNet was released, we re-implement FSRNet with Pytorch". I would suggest highlighting this difference in Table 1 with ‘*’ or similar symbols. (3) When comparing the proposed method with the SOTA method, the computational complexity and parameter amount of each method should also be listed, which will help to study the efficiency of the network. (4) I think the author missed some existing methods, especially the SOTA method since 2020. I think the author needs to add several recent SOTA methods and compare the proposed method. Comments: This manuscript should be resubmitted after being revised according to the follows as Comment 1：The overall framework of Figure 1 needs to be properly described. And some symbols in the figure are confused. Comment 2：RCAB is used in the proposed method, but its introduction and implementation details are missing. Comment 3：In page 6, the GFNet is compared with state-of-the-art methods and achieves better results. However, the comparison methods are put forward from 2014 to 2019. References are not the recent one and some appropriate key studies are missing. Comment 4：In Abstract, “the proposed network is able to reconstruct fine face images with a performance improvement of 0.3 dB PSNR and 0.82 dB PNSR”. This is really confusing. What is the comparison method? How do you get the results of 0.3 dB PSNR and 0.82 dB PNSR? These are not mentioned in the text. Comment 5：The format of references is incorrect, such as [1], [12], [14], [15], [20], etc. Comment 6：To have an unbiased view in the paper, there should be some discussions on the limitations of the method. Comment 7：The grammar needs to be carefully revised. There are many spelling mistakes, such as "dsuper-resolution" on page 2. |
回复此楼» 猜你喜欢
找工作过程中碰到好多人问南京某新换校长211的政策，规定如下
已经有17人回复
-
研二光催化6月底四篇二区什么水平
已经有8人回复
-
24年 申博 化学/材料 一作6篇sci
已经有4人回复
-
两类问题算是白选了~
已经有6人回复
-
南京大学-广州大学联合招聘博士后 欢迎广大优秀人才！！！
已经有8人回复
-
期刊推荐
已经有5人回复
-
東京大学 应用化学专业柳田研究室 招收修士/博士生
已经有5人回复
-
真的好想读博！
已经有9人回复
-
聊天
已经有9人回复
-
工作问题求助
已经有5人回复
» 抢金币啦！回帖就可以得到:
-
繁星点点，我在寂静中感受你的温暖
+3/147
-
坐标北京 诚征女友
+5/135
-
南方科技大学招聘行政助理
+1/82
-
材料表面处理方向研究助理或博士后招聘
+1/81
-
四川大学优青魏强课题组招聘“细胞力学生物学”博士后
+1/36
-
湖南科技大学 材料学院 金属材料系 招聘教师
+1/33
-
郑州大学光电器件方向招收一名博士
+1/32
-
四川大学优青魏强课题组招聘“细胞力学生物学”博士后
+1/32
-
【诚聘英才】在京央企储能工程师
+1/31
-
深圳技术大学刘清侠院士团队与马来亚大学 招收钠离子电池方向联合培养博士生 研究助理
+1/31
-
专业提供SEM-EDS/NMR/FTIR/DSC/TGA/DMA/TMA/GCMS 加扣870 559 66
+1/23
-
专业提供SEM-EDS/NMR/FTIR/DSC/TGA/DMA/TMA/GCMS 加扣870 559 66
+1/22
-
专业提供SEM-EDS/NMR/FTIR/DSC/TGA/DMA/TMA/GCMS 加扣870 559 66
+1/21
-
专业提供SEM-EDS/NMR/FTIR/DSC/TGA/DMA/TMA/GCMS 加扣870 559 66
+1/20
-
中国科学院海洋研究所海洋生物制品课题组招聘“博士后”
+1/7
-
先进复合材料力学与智能制造团队招聘：研究助理教授、博士后、科研助理（长期有效）
+1/6
-
南京大学高亚飞课题组招聘金属有机化学研究助理（可转组内博士）
+1/6
-
氮化硼纳米管在铝合金中的使用
+1/4
-
求珠三角地区访学或合作交流，高分子材料方向
+1/1
-
211博后出站求职，第一性原理+分子动力学模拟+机器学习力场开发
+1/1
+3/147
8楼2021-12-01 06:51:07
10楼2021-12-01 07:12:07
5楼2021-11-30 22:53:56
6楼2021-11-30 23:18:58
9楼2021-12-01 06:52:09
12楼2021-12-01 08:17:12
|
本帖内容被屏蔽 |
13楼2021-12-01 09:54:02
14楼2021-12-03 16:39:44
15楼2021-12-04 07:49:27
16楼2021-12-04 08:30:49
17楼2021-12-18 10:35:26
18楼2021-12-18 10:44:05
简单回复
tzynew2楼
2021-11-30 22:35
回复
罗爱我(金币+1): 谢谢参与
8 发自小木虫Android客户端
bjdxyxy3楼
2021-11-30 22:36
回复
罗爱我(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫Android客户端
6号枫木塔4楼
2021-11-30 22:41
回复
啥也不hui7楼
2021-11-30 23:30
回复
nono200911楼
2021-12-01 07:58
回复
罗爱我(金币+1): 谢谢参与
。 发自小木虫Android客户端
