|
[求助]
JAP 怎么出现两次Decision Letter Being Prepared,前后相差10天,是否拒稿?已有2人参与
投稿journal of applied physics 两个审稿人,一个审稿人提出语言问题和参考文献引用问题,其他评价都好Reviewer #1 Evaluations:
Does the manuscript present original and timely results that significantly advance the knowledge in applied physics: Yes
Does the manuscript report on convincing and rigorous data methods and analysis: Yes
Is the manuscript clearly written in correct English well organized and free from ambiguities: Yes
Is the title descriptive of the contents concise interesting and free of acronyms: Yes
Does the abstract adequately and clearly describe the contents (problem approach findings) of the paper: Yes
Are the figures in the manuscript necessary adequate well presented and clearly labeled: Yes
Is the reference list appropriate: No,
In summary, I would recommend it for publication if my concerns are sufficiently considered.
另一个审稿人提出语言问题和原创性不足,
Reviewer #2 Evaluations:
Does the manuscript present original and timely results that significantly advance the knowledge in applied physics: No
Does the manuscript report on convincing and rigorous data methods and analysis: Yes
Is the manuscript clearly written in correct English well organized and free from ambiguities: No
Is the title descriptive of the contents concise interesting and free of acronyms: Yes
Does the abstract adequately and clearly describe the contents (problem approach findings) of the paper: Yes
Are the figures in the manuscript necessary adequate well presented and clearly labeled: Yes
Is the reference list appropriate: Yes
编辑意见 believe that your work has merit, but have made a number of recommendations that need to be taken into account if I am going to consider the manuscript further.
修改稿上传了
Decision Letter Being Prepared 21-Oct-2018 07:53:48
Associate Editor Decision Completed 21-Oct-2018 07:53:48
Decision Letter Being Prepared 11-Oct-2018 16:27:44
Associate Editor Decision Completed 11-Oct-2018 16:27:44
Associate Editor Decision Started 11-Oct-2018 08:36:07
All Reviews Received 11-Oct-2018 08:36:07
Review Received 02-Oct-2018 23:38:31
All Reviewers Secured 02-Oct-2018 23:31:22
Review Started 02-Oct-2018 23:31:22
First Reviewer Secured 02-Oct-2018 23:31:22
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 02-Oct-2018 23:31:21
Review Started 30-Sep-2018 09:28:43
Potential Reviewer Agreed to Review 30-Sep-2018 09:28:43
Potential Reviewer Invitation(s) Sent 30-Sep-2018 08:32:03
Potential Reviewers Selected 30-Sep-2018 08:31:56
Reviewer Assignment Started 26-Sep-2018 15:46:44
Securing Associate Editor 26-Sep-2018 15:46:44
Securing Editor 26-Sep-2018 15:46:43
Submission Check by Editorial Office Completed 26-Sep-2018 15:46:43
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 26-Sep-2018 01:31:04
Securing Editor 26-Sep-2018 01:31:04
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 26-Sep-2018 01:31:03
Awaiting Author Adjustment/Approval of Converted Files 25-Sep-2018 11:41:49
Submission Check by Editorial Office Failed 25-Sep-2018 11:41:49
Submission Check by Editorial Office Started 25-Sep-2018 10:10:16
Securing Editor 25-Sep-2018 10:10:16
Manuscript Submitted to Editorial Office 25-Sep-2018 10:10:15
File Conversion Completed 25-Sep-2018 10:09:00
Waiting for File Conversion 25-Sep-2018 09:55:57
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 25-Sep-2018 09:55:31
File Conversion Completed 25-Sep-2018 09:55:3 |
|