24小时热门版块排行榜     意得辑论文润色满3千送无线充电宝

查看: 300  |  回复: 6

chen89714

新虫 (初入文坛)

[交流] IET投稿后三个月Decline to resubmit revised paper已有4人参与

投稿IET Generation, Transmission & Distribution后三个月被拒并要求重投,麻烦大家帮忙看看审稿建议,之后提交修改稿录用的几率大不大,谢谢!
Reviewer: 1

Comments to the Author
The paper deals with a complex problem in relation to the erosion of circuit breaker contacts after repeated short circuits.
The work is interesting, but uses approximations and laws that remain valid in well defined experimental conditions. In order to be published, the authors are asked to respond to the following suggestions and remarks.
1. The authors are asked to give in the introduction how they distinguish between the arc resistance and the resistance of circuit breaker poles contacts.
2. Please verify if the pressure of SF6 varies in the same direction than the DRM (dynamic resistance of contact).
3. In figure 1, the authors are asked to give further explanation about the considered values of the capacity C=16.8 mF and L = 0.6 mH.  
4. Figure 5 wants for references and extensive explanations.  
5. Concerning figure 6: The authors are asked to make in which type of breaker this type of arc cutting is operated?  
6. One of the used approximations by authors concerns the mass loss of arcing contact and the cylindrical shape.  The authors are asked to justify this hypothesis.
7. Please give more information concerning the used alloy (CuW80), especially some references where this alloy is currently used.
8. Equation 7 considers the enthalpy of the contacts from 20 °C to the evaporation of the contacts material. This needs further explanation and discussion with regard to the real temperatures at which the contacts are submitted during arcing occurrence.
9. It will be more relevant and necessary to give more justification and explanation concerning equation 10.
10. The value of the determined length decrement of arcing contact (L = 0.268 mm) needs for references and more explanation. What are the works that already determined this length?
11. A comparison between the number of experimental erosion tests and normal life CBs operations is needed.


Reviewer: 2

Comments to the Author
In this manuscript, the authors tried to assess the condition of contact sets in SF6 CBs without dismantling. They used five parameters (Rm average main contact resistance, Ra average arcing contact resistance, Lm length of main contact part, La length of arcing contact part, Lc overtravel) which were extracted from R-L curve, to evaluate the conditions of SF6 contact sets. However, the R-L curve was obtained based on their experimental equipment and the errors of the results were not provided in this paper. So the five parameters extracted from R-L curves were not reliable.
On the other hand, the principle used to define the critical value of the five parameters (Rm, Ra, Lm, La and Lc) was not reliable too. For example, they proposed that the critical values of Rm and Ra, were the highest ones from R-L curve Fig.8. But the reason was not given. So the discussion and conclusion should be invalid.
The current and voltage during the operations were not shown in this manuscript. To assess the contact sets, the authors should compare the R-L curve and the characteristics of current and voltage. Finally, they would give some useful and reliable information.
回复此楼
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

国际科学编辑

铁杆木虫 (职业作家)



小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包,谢谢回帖
reviewer2的意见很negative,估计很玄。建议修改后改投。

发自小木虫IOS客户端
2楼2016-03-14 11:39:55
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

hequnqun

金虫 (初入文坛)


小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包,谢谢回帖
楼主你好!请问你在做实验时用到了SF6吧,我想请问你一下,你们是用什么仪器来检测SF6气体的呢?我们实验室现在需要用SF6来作为示踪剂来测量室内外的空气对流速率,所以需要购置一台SF6的定量检测仪器,不需要功能太强大,只是检测线能低一些,最好是能达到0.1ppm,另外,最好不要是手持的那种,希望楼主能给点建议,谢谢!
3楼2016-03-28 13:52:11
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
4楼2016-03-28 14:11:39
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

pydc1991

铁虫 (小有名气)


小木虫: 金币+0.5, 给个红包,谢谢回帖
我也是,一个星期之前收到的消息,被拒然后重投,现在在犹豫是否要重新投,还是换一个EI。
5楼2016-03-28 14:29:34
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

chen89714

新虫 (初入文坛)

引用回帖:
3楼: Originally posted by hequnqun at 2016-03-28 13:52:11
楼主你好!请问你在做实验时用到了SF6吧,我想请问你一下,你们是用什么仪器来检测SF6气体的呢?我们实验室现在需要用SF6来作为示踪剂来测量室内外的空气对流速率,所以需要购置一台SF6的定量检测仪器,不需要功能太 ...

我们做实验时没有用到六氟化硫监测相关的仪器,只是简单通过断路器本身的压力表读取压力数据,具体的你可以咨询下gis方向的,他们应该更清楚。

发自小木虫IOS客户端

» 本帖已获得的红花(最新10朵)

6楼2016-04-07 12:19:25
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖

hequnqun

金虫 (初入文坛)

送红花一朵
引用回帖:
6楼: Originally posted by chen89714 at 2016-04-07 12:19:25
我们做实验时没有用到六氟化硫监测相关的仪器,只是简单通过断路器本身的压力表读取压力数据,具体的你可以咨询下gis方向的,他们应该更清楚。
...

好的,谢谢啦
7楼2016-04-07 17:22:13
已阅   回复此楼   关注TA 给TA发消息 送TA红花 TA的回帖
相关版块跳转 我要订阅楼主 chen89714 的主题更新
最具人气热帖推荐 [查看全部] 作者 回/看 最后发表
[论文投稿] cej送审的拒稿率大概有多少? 100+3 Yft199495 2020-10-22 4/200 2020-10-24 21:25 by streamwood
[基金申请] 浙江省自然科学基金已经可以查到项目批准号! +23 tjzhao 2020-10-19 46/2300 2020-10-24 21:15 by tigershark
[论文投稿] 德国应用化学投稿一月没有消息 +6 小白zhen菜 2020-10-19 11/550 2020-10-24 20:25 by 嘎色达瓦
[教师之家] 厦门大学助理教授值不值做? +9 fjswrww 2020-10-20 9/450 2020-10-24 18:04 by 陈宝群
[硕博家园] 作为一个博士 很讨厌学习怎么办 +13 静静静肖 2020-10-21 17/850 2020-10-24 16:06 by 静静静肖
[化工设备] 反应釜 20+3 电池负极 2020-10-20 7/350 2020-10-24 15:11 by 噬魂丨温柔吻
[分析] 自己制备的柴油想检测其中的组成成分 +3 yuoknow 2020-10-18 3/150 2020-10-24 11:01 by 柳絮虫
[找工作] 博士毕业很迷茫,江苏浙江如何选,去拼一拼211还是二本副高 +7 七月魂舞 2020-10-21 7/350 2020-10-24 09:02 by zirconi_
[文学芳草园] 一片良田留不住(2020轻叹) +3 i7366 2020-10-20 3/150 2020-10-24 07:51 by yebo_
[基金申请] 省基金又没中 +13 renyz518 2020-10-23 13/650 2020-10-23 20:15 by jqthappyfly
[找工作] 应届土博offer选择:北京211特聘副教授VS上海211讲师? +16 沈知术 2020-10-19 21/1050 2020-10-23 19:42 by sunny_lala
[找工作] 博士毕业找高校工作 +6 zhy10sdust 2020-10-18 7/350 2020-10-23 17:27 by 1176823037
[论文投稿] 请帮忙分析一下,主编的意思是拒绝,建议重投吗? +4 海宝心声 2020-10-22 4/200 2020-10-23 15:33 by tjuabraham
[基金申请] 国自然工作时间限制? 60+3 seabert 2020-10-21 7/350 2020-10-23 12:29 by nkqijw
[论文投稿] 现在ACS投稿系统变了吗?现在有under review 了? +5 linxuhuizj 2020-10-21 12/600 2020-10-22 00:14 by li19891108
[教师之家] 打算购买一台工作站用于计算分析,有了解的虫友能给点建议吗? +5 无名小冰冰 2020-10-18 14/700 2020-10-21 20:41 by dolphin100
[版块工场] 【早起签到贴】2020年10月21日(q q 48626260 进群申请:小木虫——您个人ID) +5 8475 2020-10-21 5/250 2020-10-21 10:04 by lishizi2010
[新药研发] 创新药药物活性成分筛选和晶型研究 +7 杂质和参比 2020-10-19 9/450 2020-10-21 09:06 by 天山明月
[考博] 申请-考核制 +3 二球悬铃木 2020-10-18 7/350 2020-10-19 20:53 by lylgszy
[版块工场] 【早起签到贴】2020年10月19日(q q 48626260 进群申请:小木虫——您个人ID) +6 8475 2020-10-19 6/300 2020-10-19 08:48 by 陈超-冶金
信息提示
请填处理意见