如题。我在11月初一个文章投了个会议（级别也不太高），12月尾初审意见如下：
Reviewer: 1
> Comments to the Author
>一些介绍文章的内容的说明. However, I think that this paper contains no novelty either in the approach nor in the results nad should not be published.
>
> Reviewer: 2
> Comments to the Author
> The authors report a study of 文章内容。 The method they use is scientifically sound, A more direct way would be to simply use 。。。, and try to obtain a three-dimensional field mapping of the surface. This can also be used to verify whether all theoretical work is sound and free from errors.（审稿人给出了他的一个建议）
>
> Another major improvement that the manuscript needs is grammatical corrections. The manuscript should go through a careful grammar check by preferably an English speaker. （语法问题）
>
> Also Figure 1 (a) and (b) are having two white/blank stripes running across. Please check.（图片的一个问题，这个看不明白）
我第一次回复时，对第一个审稿人，是申辩，说自己的文章有一些创新性。
对第二个审稿人给出的建议也回绝了，认为这个建议是无效的。（他的这个建议我们不能论证，因为我们的实验条件难以实现）
第三一就是说我的文章 语法有所修改。
两周后，就是前几天，第二次审稿结果出来了，下面是编辑给的邮件：
It is my pleasure to inform you that the manuscript listed below, which you submitted to Transactions on Magnetics - Conferences, has been accepted for publication. In order for us to proceed, you need to do the following:

1. Please check the bottom of this message and your Author Center on Manuscript Central to see if there are any reviewers' comments that you still need to address before you prepare your final version. Complete all required corrections and/or modifications required by the reviewers or your editor.（这里说还要对审稿人做出回应）
2. Main manuscript file:
（接下来是一些格式什么的嘱咐，和期限，一周内交出 final submission）
然后是两个审稿人的意见
Reviewer: 1
Comments to the Author
I still maintain the opinion that the approach is very well known. In any case the research is well conducted, the manuscript is free of errors and despite the absence of any novelty, I accept the Editor decision.

Reviewer: 2
Comments to the Author
1) cannot find which paragraphs have been modified in the newer corrected version;
2) did not find the responses to comments satisfactory;
3) still needs major grammatical improvement (in fact no apparent corrections were found).
请问，这种情况下，我该如何回复？还需要对两个审稿人作一一回复吗？（如果要回复，怎么样说好）。关于语法和英语，已经在改了。编辑会把 final submission 重新发给两个审稿人吗？如果修改或回答不好，是不是又有可能变成被拒？我这个文章质量不高，这点我认可。 返回小木虫查看更多