文章被拒重投求助
年前投了一篇一区文章,审稿两月刚回邮件,一大修,一拒,编辑给最终意见拒,不过邮件有个“However”,后面有段话,请大家分析一下,编辑是拒了让重投的意思吗???再投的话是不是有希望?导师比较喜欢该期刊,所以一定得让修,不过我心里是没底,唉,说多了都是泪……
“I am sorry about the outcome and appreciate that you are disappointed with my decision. I encourage you to continue to support the journal, including submission of future manuscripts.
However, if you can improve manuscript significantly by carrying more experiment and providing more insightful discussions based on the reviewers' comments and suggestions, you may submit the revised version of manuscript as a new submission. In this case, please mention that this manuscript (along with the original manuscript number) has ever been submitted before in the cover letter and include the 'point-by-point response letter'. The same reviewers can review this manuscript again.
Thank you for giving us the opportunity to consider your work”
返回小木虫查看更多
顶
跟我经历一样,之前投jmca材料一区的期刊,审稿一个月,两个审稿人,一个大修,一个直接拒,结果编辑给出重新投稿的意见,于是乎大修改二十天,于今年2月10号重新投稿,等了十天,直接被接收!
,
如果不补实验或者大改的话,也没必要再投
相当于大大修,我也有过相同的经历,按照审稿意见认真逐一修改回复,很可能接收。我的最终就接收了。
好好改,重投吧
给了重投就是有希望 好好按意见修改
同感心累,修改这个过程是多么含辛
让你好好改改,还是有希望的